Boxing News 24 Forum

Boxing News 24 Forum (http://www.boxingforum24.com/index.php)
-   Classic Boxing Forum (http://www.boxingforum24.com/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   The Murderers Row - Explain their style (http://www.boxingforum24.com/showthread.php?t=180884)

GPater11093 11-03-2009 11:50 AM

The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
i know some of you gusy really know about this period.

Ive been reading lan Rpsenfelds book on Burley (a real boxing geeks book and i love it)

and i cant fathom Burleys style. He appears to have been a sharp shooting, boxing puncher early in his career. He then goes into a more boxer-puncher but with bobbing and weaving then he went into a boxer who jumped in with hard shots. Anyone shed any light.

also can people help me with the styles of

Cocoa Kid
Holman Williams
Llyod Marshall
Jack Chase

Sweet Pea 11-03-2009 12:13 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GPater11093 (Post 5313224)
and i cant fathom Burleys style. He appears to have been a sharp shooting, boxing puncher early in his career. He then goes into a more boxer-puncher but with bobbing and weaving then he went into a boxer who jumped in with hard shots.

:lol:Oh, Greg.

GPater11093 11-03-2009 12:15 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sweet Pea (Post 5313386)
:lol:Oh, Greg.

whats wrong with that? You know what i mean it slightly changes through time but they are all quite odd styles.

PowerPuncher 11-03-2009 01:40 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Do we have 1 or 2 fights of Burleys? You can only honestly assess what you've seen. We have none of the rest. From what I've seen Burley was a great judge of distance, rolled his weight from 1 foot to another to set traps or make feints and lean back and counter, his footwork I find similar to Floyd Mayweathers, very much a radar type fighter looking to slip shots, a side on boxer that likes to slip back and counter his right over the jab, great use of angles, also seems to potshot allot. Similar to FMJ except Burley actually knows how to throw a proper punch, this could be partly because hes a smaller man fighting a LHW too.

Archie Moore was a Burley fan and he based his style on Burley's a bit imo using some of his moves.

janitor 11-03-2009 02:23 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
I can't think of anybody since Burley who I would compare his style to.

He is a "what if technical boxing had taken a diferent path back in the 1920s"
type of proposition.

Sweet Pea 11-03-2009 02:29 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GPater11093 (Post 5313396)
whats wrong with that? You know what i mean it slightly changes through time but they are all quite odd styles.

It was your description of his styles that tickled me, not your stance on his evolution as a fighter.

TheGreatA 11-03-2009 02:53 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by PowerPuncher (Post 5314025)
Do we have 1 or 2 fights of Burleys? You can only honestly assess what you've seen. We have none of the rest. From what I've seen Burley was a great judge of distance, rolled his weight from 1 foot to another to set traps or make feints and lean back and counter, his footwork I find similar to Floyd Mayweathers, very much a radar type fighter looking to slip shots, a side on boxer that likes to slip back and counter his right over the jab, great use of angles, also seems to potshot allot. Similar to FMJ except Burley actually knows how to throw a proper punch, this could be partly because hes a smaller man fighting a LHW too.

Archie Moore was a Burley fan and he based his style on Burley's a bit imo using some of his moves.

There's film of Lloyd Marshall. I've heard comparisons with Archie Moore although I'm not sure if they're 100% accurate.

cotto20 11-03-2009 03:35 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
How come oakland billy smith never gets a mention he beat harold johnson, jack chase, lloyd marshall and got a draw with archie moore, he never got a title shot, does he even get a mention in the book your reading gp pater?

Bokaj 11-03-2009 03:45 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
It seems many of the "murderer's row" had quite unorthodox styles. Burley, Moore - Marshall if he was similar to Moore - and also Walcott, who could be said to have spent a large part of his career on "murderer's row" before he got his shot. Like Moore did.

That could well be because they probably wasn't that well managed and trained in their formative years, and therefore in large part adopted very personal styles. But some of their moves seems to have been incorporated in the text book to a degree later on. For example Moore's upper body movement and cross armed guard.

Were these guys the first slick, unorthodox technicians, perhaps? How important have they've been for the evolution of boxing? Who are their heirs today? Toney, Hopkins?

TheGreatA 11-03-2009 03:57 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bokaj (Post 5314933)
It seems many of the "murderer's row" had quite unorthodox styles. Burley, Moore - Marshall if he was similar to Moore - and also Walcott, who could be said to have spent a large part of his career on "murderer's row" before he got his shot. Like Moore did.

That could well be because they probably wasn't that well managed and trained in their formative years, and therefore in large part adopted very personal styles. But some of their moves seems to have been incorporated in the text book to a degree later on. For example Moore's upper body movement and cross armed guard.

Were these guys the first slick, unorthodox technicians, perhaps? How important have they've been for the evolution of boxing? Who are their heirs today? Toney, Hopkins?

Hopkins and Toney both name Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore, Jersey Joe Walcott as inspirations so I guess they could be considered the "heirs" of these fighters.

Charley Burley's former sparring parner A.J. Nelson said Roy Jones reminded him of Burley.

Bokaj 11-03-2009 04:20 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGreatA (Post 5315007)
Hopkins and Toney both name Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore, Jersey Joe Walcott as inspirations so I guess they could be considered the "heirs" of these fighters.

Charley Burley's former sparring parner A.J. Nelson said Roy Jones reminded him of Burley.

Interesting. Thanks.

My2Sense 11-03-2009 04:28 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGreatA (Post 5315007)

Charley Burley's former sparring parner A.J. Nelson said Roy Jones reminded him of Burley.

That's who I would compare him to.

Maybe Marshall could be compared to Wilfredo Gomez? :think

GPater11093 11-03-2009 04:53 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sweet Pea (Post 5314383)
It was your description of his styles that tickled me, not your stance on his evolution as a fighter.

just say stuff how i see it



Quote:

Originally Posted by St_Boxing_J12 (Post 5314859)
How come oakland billy smith never gets a mention he beat harold johnson, jack chase, lloyd marshall and got a draw with archie moore, he never got a title shot, does he even get a mention in the book your reading gp pater?

because theres some footage of Billy Smith available

also he does get a mention as the book is about the scene as a hole really and it charts alot of the Murderers row with Smith getting a mention.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bokaj (Post 5314933)
It seems many of the "murderer's row" had quite unorthodox styles. Burley, Moore - Marshall if he was similar to Moore - and also Walcott, who could be said to have spent a large part of his career on "murderer's row" before he got his shot. Like Moore did.

That could well be because they probably wasn't that well managed and trained in their formative years, and therefore in large part adopted very personal styles. But some of their moves seems to have been incorporated in the text book to a degree later on. For example Moore's upper body movement and cross armed guard.

Were these guys the first slick, unorthodox technicians, perhaps? How important have they've been for the evolution of boxing? Who are their heirs today? Toney, Hopkins?

interesting that

They was mentioning how like Williams despite being unorthodox still had some of the Detriot style in him and Burley still having that Pittsburgh style in him again despite being unorthodox.

In the newspaper articles quoted they are never referred to as being weird stylists or unorthodox but rather as great technicians and all of them were great defensive technicians. Definitly slick as they were all reknowned for there offence aswell.

They cant play too much of a part in the evolution of boxing as there is not alot of films of them so people cant watch them to see what they did different etc.. which is a shame its probably why people like Fitzsimmons despite being an unorthodox style it never caught on as people didnt have the chance to see it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheGreatA (Post 5315007)
Hopkins and Toney both name Ezzard Charles, Archie Moore, Jersey Joe Walcott as inspirations so I guess they could be considered the "heirs" of these fighters.

Charley Burley's former sparring parner A.J. Nelson said Roy Jones reminded him of Burley.

Interesting about Hop and Toney as they are old school fighters. Not completly dissimilar to the murderers row either.

also interesting about the Jones Jr comparison.

Quote:

Originally Posted by My2Sense (Post 5315227)
That's who I would compare him to.

Maybe Marshall could be compared to Wilfredo Gomez? :think

high praise indeed.

Bokaj 11-03-2009 05:04 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GPater11093 (Post 5315412)
They cant play too much of a part in the evolution of boxing as there is not alot of films of them so people cant watch them to see what they did different etc.. which is a shame its probably why people like Fitzsimmons despite being an unorthodox style it never caught on as people didnt have the chance to see it.

There is plenty of film on Walcott and Moore. And Moore was in turn influenced by Burley it seems. Then we also have the perhaps most influential trainer post WWII, Eddie Futch, who was a huge Burley fan.

GPater11093 11-03-2009 05:07 PM

Re: The Murderers Row - Explain their style
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bokaj (Post 5315485)
There is plenty of film on Walcott and Moore. And Moore was in turn influenced by Burley it seems. Then we also have the perhaps most influential trainer post WWII, Eddie Futch, who was a huge Burley fan.

good points there

Moore was a huge Burley fan, not sure how similar they are though but Moore also went into training albeit not too heavily he must have imparted some tips to fight liek Burley.

Futch yeh forgot about him he was a huge Burley fan also didnt he work Willaims corner afew times?


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.0
Copyright ©2000 - 2016, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Boxing News 24 Forum 2015