Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

So apparently Floyd is the greatest 130 fighter of all time.

But who beat the better fighters at the 130 weight.

Floyd or Manny

Manny best wins: Morales twice, Barrera, Marquez, Solis

Floyd: Hernandez, Corales,

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

So your saying Pac is the greatest 130lber ever?


I know you rank him the best 147lber ever... So I see where your going

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

i don't rate him as the best at any weight ever. not even top 5 at any weight ever.

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

Sure :lol: :thumbsup

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

don't be too shocked. Manny is good, but not that good.

The purpose of this thread is to show, you can't call floyd the best 130 ever, when even manny has a better 130 resume than him. And he not one of the best 130 fighters.

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

Manny has an exceptional resume, spanning multiple weight classes.


Personally I even consider the DLH win a good win because of the challenge of taking the fight in the first place. When the fight was signed, no way did Pac know DLH was coming into the ring on an IV. Therefore should be credited for that performance.


Mayweather has a great resume and has beat great fighters throughout all the weights, but his resume isnt nearly as deep as Pacs at any weight (bar 135 really)

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

Excuse me but isn't Pac the GOAT in two divisions?

At the 145lbs and 150lbs divisions I have Pac as the undisputed no.1 with no-one anywhere near him

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

i don't like his 135 resume personally. but it is better than pacs who only fought there once.

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

that's a good point is that. keep them coming

I would have given Mayweather number 1 at 145 due to his dominating performance against marque, but he failed to make the weight.

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

:nono

Marquez at the last minute asked for a higher weight

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

Not even an HM for Whitaker? :-(

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

He never won the 145lbs title pac-man did

:deal:deal:deal

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

H2H, Whitaker at 145 beats Pac at 145. No Doubt.

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

We don't know that, Pac was a beast back in his 145lbs days not the shadow we see today. But I guess as Marquez showed Pac don't like the defensive counter punchers and sweet pea is right up that alley. However, Pac is the longest standing belt holder and lineal champ at 145. Something Sweet Pea can't contend with

:deal:deal:deal

Re: Who has the better resume at 130 - Floyd or Pac
 

Mayweather is arguably the best (not the greatest!) 130 lbs boxer ever.
So the wins he has are more likely to be more convincing.

It's not just about winning, it is how you won. (A KO in round 1 victory is worth more than a SD12 victory)
Paccy fought better men, Mayweather whooped more ass.