My view is that the state of a fighters reflexes is the clock by which to guage which class a fighter belongs to:
Peak reflexes, but doesnt have the experience you use them to the best of their ability
Peak reflexes with the experience to use them to their fullest
Reflexes have slowed down
Reflexes are completely gone and shouldnt be fighting anymore.
Applying this to Toney:
Green until around McCallum I
Prime form McCallum I - ???
Past prime by the time he got to cw
shot - post Sam Peter I
Anyone here agree or disagree?
Not sure when Toney was past prime