Originally Posted by Legend X
Yeah, I get it. I just don't agree with it.
For example, if Andre Ward decided to fight and beat a load of ranked heavyweights but he weighs in at 168, I'd give those achievements as proof that he's a great super-middle as well as good cw/hw.
That's a perfectly valid conclusion also.
In that situation i'd call him a great heavyweight and give him p4p kudos.
It's something I deliberated about for a while (due to armstrong actually) and I decided the only way to stop a victory counting as double (like in your model he gets credit both as a smw and hw) is to go with the weight of the heaviest fighter.