Rek and I were debating this on another thread. I thought I had Werdum comfortably ahead of Randy at hw, but now not quite so sure.
Please read, vote and explain...
Werdum at HW:
Wins - Fedor, Overeem, Aleks Emelianenko, Bigfoot, Gonzaga (twice), Nelson
Losses - Nogueira, Kharitonov, Arlovski, JDS, Overeem
Couture at HW:
Wins - Sylvia, Gonzaga, Rizzo (twice), Randleman, Belfort, Smith
Losses - Barnett, Rodriguez, Lesnar, Nogueira
Consider these questions:
- Who beat the better fighters?
- Whose losses are more damaging?
- Who had better longevity in the division?
- Who would win h2h between the best Werdum and the best Couture?
- Are there are any other factors you think are relevant here?