I read this thread and it's an epic fail in reading comprehension.
What can I say? Word ****ing games seem to be the prevalent theme.
I have been in fight gyms since I was six years old - James23 definition of what defines a MMA fighter is 100% correct. I would disagree about the "even ground" however if you talk the talk you better walk the walk as Toney had to.
The moment a boxer learns one pure vanilla submission or wrestling technique, the moment he learns one pure vanilla Muay Thai technique then he has by generally accepted definition learnt a bit, some, lots or crap mixed martial arts.
Put it in the real world - the moment a boxer talks shit about MMA fighters in a MMA gym then he is expected to jump in and show how superior boxing is. If the boxer won by atomic drop or flying off the top turnbuckle then I have hard ****in time relating that to his boxing skills.
JeanPaulValley - hang your head in shame for even thinking this was a good thread and actually agreeing with Popkins and typing shit.