Originally Posted by Lance_Uppercut
So now Shane was P4P #4, not #3? Are you seriously going to try and use that as some form of justification of Shane's worth? Trying to mix P4P rankings with division rankings is pointless. Apples and oranges.
Shane was recognized as the champ in the division, was a top 5 fighter P4P, and just beaten the "scariest" guy in the division.
Saying that a Cotto catchweight bout when he has no trainer and had gotten beat down by Margarito recently is a better win is pretty silly logic.