Originally Posted by general zod
A great fighter is someone who regularly turned in top performances against solid opposition.
An ATG is someone who makes the top ten of an original weight class
Calzaghe fits neither of those descriptions
I think you're stupid to disregard SMW completely just to ensure no-one can praise Calzaghe.
Especially considering that it has been one of the best weight classes since the mid to late 90's.
Calzaghe is a great fighter no matter how much you want to deny it.