Originally Posted by janitor
Lets say that we exclude all acomplishments above the middleweight limit.
Is it still a competitive fight?
Yeah I think it's fair to say Greb has the edge in resume and haglerzon have the edge in achievement. They also have the benefit of film.
The only other man who could be reasonably debated imo is Robinson on the strength of his perfection in stopping La Motta. There's noone outside them 4 I'd consider a worthy number 1.