View Single Post
Old 01-18-2013, 01:42 PM   #986
edward morbius
Contender
ESB Senior Member
 
Join Date: Sep 2011
Posts: 1,129
vCash: 500
Default Re: Wladimir Klitschko vs. Rocky Marciano

"Heavyweights are more widely recruited"

Here is a list from the 1952 Ring rankings of rated and Class A & B fighters--top 100--from outside the USA

Cesar Brion--Argentina
Hein Ten Hoff--Germany
Johnny Williams--UK
Jack Gardner--UK
Omelio Agramonte--Cuba
Karel Sys--Belgium
-----------------
class A (top 50)

Ansell Adams--Trinidad
Reg Andrews--UK
Johnny Arthur--South Africa
Frank Bell--UK
Abel Cestac--Argentina
Arturo Godoy--Chile
Don Scott--UK
Paddy Slavin--Ireland
Piet Wilde--Belgium
Jo Weidin--Austria

Class B (50-100)

Uber Bacilieri--Italy
Gino Buonvino--Italy
Paco Bueno--Spain
Jimmy Carroll--UK
Allan Cooke--UK
Robert Eugene--Belgium
Tommy Farr--UK
Jan Klein--Holland
Wilson Kohlbrecher--Germany
Jack Marr--Australia
Stephane Olek--France
Heinz Neuhaus--Germany
Kurt Schiegl--Austria
Eddie Vann--UK
Werner Wiegand--Luxemburg

Clearly it is a little more than the USA or UK (I will give you credit for meaning the British Empire thus including Canada and Australia)

Top heavyweights were coming from Western Europe and Latin America, and it is certainly possible that both areas were more active boxing centers then than they are now. Not only possible but likely.

One thing to consider is that the world population was much different then than now, with a far higher % of the population in Europe and North America than today.

The 1950's had champions from central Africa (Hogan Bassey) and Asia (Yoshio Sharai) but these areas did not impact heavyweight boxing back then.

**The Soviets and other eastern bloc countries did compete in the Olympics in the 1950's but did not do that well. There is no reason to suspect that there was some great fighter out there but unknown. This argument is the flip side of arguing that the Klitschkos would not be champions if the best American big men were not in the NFL or NBA.
edward morbius is offline  Top
Reply With Quote