View Single Post
Old 01-24-2013, 05:30 AM   #16
ESB Junkie
East Side VIP
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: The Garden Of England
Posts: 31,594
vCash: 1000
Default Re: Tunney V Sharkey, Willard, Brennan,Miske, Firpo?

Originally Posted by McGrain View Post
That's true, Miske might have more chance back in the day. I wouldbn't bet on it though.

I personally don't think that Loughran is better than Gibbons and he obviously wasn't better than Greb, so i don't think this holds much water. I don't think a draw over 8 rounds is indicative of Tunney's "form" versus boxers. I think that his KO wins over Gibbons and Carpantier and decision wins versus Levinsky and Smith (neither of which were that close) are far more telling.

Huge punchers KO superby gifted technicians all the time and it was more common in this era than in later eras. I don't think that Firpo would beat Tunney - at all - but I think it is more likely that he would KO Tunney than that Miske would out-box Tunney.

He was only in the neighbourhood of being out-boxed once - both Dempsey and Greb came close to stopping him.

Yeah, i would make Sharkey my first choice and Firpo my second. Hyper-aggressive tough punchers are difficult for top pro's because they don't obey the rules. I doubt very many people would be picking Baer to dismantle Schmeling were it not for the fact that it actually happened, but as soon as you have a puncher that aggressive in the ring, **** can happen.
I give an in form Sharkey the best shot too. As you stated, wild ,unpredictable swingers can give problems to clever boxers.

Ali v Bonavena ????
mcvey is offline  Top
Reply With Quote