Originally Posted by beat down
Froch based on quality of resume. Calzaghe is the better boxer though but froch has tested himself more
but Froch has failed two of his tests and IMO lost against Dirrell also. Calzaghe's resume is not great, but he has the win over Hopkins and the win over Kessler, who Froch lost to. Then there is Eubank and Reid. Because of this, he edges Froch, even if you give Froch the win against Dirrell. There's no that much in it in terms of achievements and Froch could surpass Calzaghe should he win against Kessler and step up to LH and beat someone like Dawson or Pascal. As it stands, Calzaghe has this title.
Head to head of course, Calzaghe pwns him.