Originally Posted by HawkFan16
I love Oscar, but by 2007 he was either very shopworn or semi-shot, depending on your point of view. Cotto was the same way.
The Duran of the Davey Moore fight beats both 2007 Oscar and 2012 Cotto. 2002 or 2003 Oscar at 154 would give him hell and stands a good chance of beating Duran and would beat Floyd though.
The Duran of the Moore fight would definately beat the Oscar Mayweather fought, without a doubt, in fact it would be a masacre. As to the 2002-003 version, I think it would be a great, great fight, but I'd still give the end to Duran if he could make it an inside fight. This version of Oscar beats Floyd at 154. And Duran beats any version of Cotto that ever stepped in the ring.