East Side Boxing Forum - View Single Post - The Transnational Boxing Rankings:Bermane Stiverne cracks the heavyweight ten

Stovepipe · 03-07-2013, 07:52 PM

ight Heavyweight
Champion Chad Dawson
1. Bernard Hopkins
2. Tavoris Cloud
3. Jean Pascal
4. Sergey Kovalev
5. Nathan Cleverly
6. Beibut Shumenov
7. Gabriel Campillo
8. Karo Murat
9. Issac Chilemba
10. Tony Bellew

Campillo kicked Cloud's ass and got crushed by Kovalev. Is it not true that most felt Campillo also beat Murat both times as well as Shumenov both times? Cloud ran about even vs Glen Johnson, an ancient version, and also has Woods, Gonzales, Zuniga and Mack on his resume. But head to head he got absolutely walloped. Seems to me that Campillo should be ranked over Cloud even after taking a drubbing by Kovalev. On the other hand, Kovalev should be ranked above both of them. I can see Dawson 1 Hops 2 Pascal 3 then Kovalev 4 and Cleverly 5 and Campillo 6 but I can't see Cloud being any higher than 6 if you want to move Cleverly below both Cloud and Campillo. But two? two? Hello? The only point in doing your own rankings is if you completely ignore very bad decisions.

03-07-2013, 07:52 PM	#186
Stovepipe Belt holder ESB Addict Join Date: Feb 2007 Posts: 3,244 vCash: 975	Re: The Transnational Boxing Rankings ight Heavyweight Champion Chad Dawson 1. Bernard Hopkins 2. Tavoris Cloud 3. Jean Pascal 4. Sergey Kovalev 5. Nathan Cleverly 6. Beibut Shumenov 7. Gabriel Campillo 8. Karo Murat 9. Issac Chilemba 10. Tony Bellew Campillo kicked Cloud's ass and got crushed by Kovalev. Is it not true that most felt Campillo also beat Murat both times as well as Shumenov both times? Cloud ran about even vs Glen Johnson, an ancient version, and also has Woods, Gonzales, Zuniga and Mack on his resume. But head to head he got absolutely walloped. Seems to me that Campillo should be ranked over Cloud even after taking a drubbing by Kovalev. On the other hand, Kovalev should be ranked above both of them. I can see Dawson 1 Hops 2 Pascal 3 then Kovalev 4 and Cleverly 5 and Campillo 6 but I can't see Cloud being any higher than 6 if you want to move Cleverly below both Cloud and Campillo. But two? two? Hello? The only point in doing your own rankings is if you completely ignore very bad decisions.
Top