Originally Posted by China_hand_Joe
There is absolutely nothing the record or the video evidence of SRR to suggest he stands a chance against Joe Calzaghe, his only hope is that Calzaghe breaks both his hands -fullstop- Cazlaghe footage shows a strong, fast, skilled fighter who isn't going to lose to a Welterweight (Robinsons optimum weight), no matter how good that Welterweight is -fullstop- And we all know Calzaghe is exceptional and better than any opponent Robinson ever faced P4P -fullstop-
Again, though, you're missing what I said. Robinson is also a top 5 MIDDLEWEIGHT in addition to being a top 2 welterweight. He carried enough pop at MIDDLEWEIGHT to wipe out the top contenders in that division.
Video evidence is clearly subjective--you see a crude caveman, most do not. But going on records? No contest here. Calzaghe faced barely any of the best supermiddleweights in his division, whereas Robinson faced and beat most of the best middleweights.