Originally Posted by fatdrunkenslob
If he can somehow get Mayweather in the ring and beat him then unify all the belts then I'm sure he is a lock for a position in the Top 5 ATG at Welterweight. For him to become the best of all time at 147 is quite a tall order and would require something spectacular like defeating every Ring ranked top welterweight and hold all four belts for many consecutive defenses for starters. Trinidad has a very good resume at Welter and I can definitely see him as a Top 10 ATG at 147 with his past accomplishments.
That's a hell of a claim, considering you have SRL, Duran, SRR, Armstrong, Hearns, Tito, Griffith, ODLH - all of whom I would choose over Marg. I would pick Williams to beat him again the same way and I make Clottey 50 50 if not a favorite, and there are just about always fighters of Clottey's lvl around at WW. We're not even sure where he fits in the top 3 RIGHT NOW, so how can you say top 5 ALL TIME? PBF probably isn't even a real ww to begin with.