Originally Posted by Street Lethal
You are leaving out Obel and Sibson. Since Leonard lost his fight to Hagler, you should put Leonard's name up there, too.
Hagler's resume at middleweight is better. However, Robinson is the only fighter in history that I think could outpoint a prime Hagler. Robinson would have to put on the fight of his life for this to happen, but Robinson could be freaky good that way.
Haglers comp is below Robinsons. If you include Haglers wins over Welters (despite them blowing upto MW) then include Robinsons.
Hagler got outpointed by Leonard, which hurts his MW legacy, Robinsons past prime losses shouldn't be held against him, ie the 1s after retirement