View Single Post
Old 09-29-2009, 09:49 PM   #65
Stonehands89
Champion
East Side Guru
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Posts: 5,270
vCash: 1000
Default Re: Ranking the Greats: your assistance please

And now the unveiling: Feel free to tear it up or commend it, but please critique it. This is quality control and collectively speaking, I trust your judgement...

Here is the first draft of rankings #10 counted down to #6:

10. Eder Jofre
(15 pt must)
RG 15
Exp 10
LGV 11
DOM 12


(10 pt must)
PLO 6
DUR 9
INT 7
TOTAL = 70


9. Charley Burley
(15 pt must)
RG 14
Exp 13
LGV 8
DOM 12

(10 pt must)
PLO 8
DUR 10
INT 7

TOTAL = 72


9. Muhammad Ali
(15 pt must)
RG 11
EXP 13
LGV 11
DOM 14

(10 pt must)
PLO 5
DUR 9
INT 9
TOTAL = 72


8. Willie Pep
(15 pt must)
RG 15
Exp 12
LGV 14
DOM 13

(10 pt must)
PLO 6
DUR 7
INT 6
TOTAL = 73


7. Archie Moore
(15 pt must)
RG 11
Exp 15
LGV 15
DOM 11

(10 pt must)
PLO 8
DUR 6
INT 8

TOTAL = 74


6. Roberto Duran
(15 pt must)
RG 13
Exp 15
LGV 13
DOM 13

(10 pt must)
PLO 8
DUR 9
INT 4
TOTAL: 75


-------------------------------------------------------------
(...I would appreciate that Burley-Ali tie being broken and so ask for argument relating to that. Also, remember to try to suspend who you feel should be included and who you think is better than who. Let's look at the values in a comapartive manner and not get locked in on the same old general debates.)
Stonehands89 is offline  Top
Reply With Quote