Originally Posted by Dipper_Brown
It would be much closer than that. This a pretty good matchup, one guy is an offensive tornado and the other is a defensive brick wall with a great jab.. It would be much closer than a wide UD.
Winky's jab is great and his defense is among the best I've ever seen, but Roy Jones Jr at 160 was unreal. I think his speed, reflexes, and movement wouldn't give Winky much of a chance to get off at the rate he likes too. There probably wouldn't be many clean punches landed, but after seeing Jones the way he handled guys at 160 and Toney at 168, I believe he would win a comfortable decision (9-3 or so) over Winky. He just wouldn't be there for Winky to hit and he would give him all sorts of angles and unorthodox punches.