Originally Posted by PetethePrince
I think their both the same. Nothing magical about P4P except for the fact of eliminating weight differences. Because after all Joe Louis would kill Sugar Ray Robinson... doesn't mean he's the better fighter. Sounds like you're over-****yzing things. I've been there before though, it can get really tricky.
Nah i'm not, because what i said was the 'best' p4p is different from the 'greatest' p4p, ie resumes. I can say that Willie Pep is one of the very best boxers ever p4p, but to me it's wrong to have him very high on a greatest p4p list, because there are a lot of others with greater resumes. If you don't get what i mean i'll just have to explain it better, but i definitely know what i mean and they're definitely not the same to me.