ESB Classic Forum All-Time Rankings by Division - P4P Survey Updated in October 2011

[robert ungurean]

L. Lewis is so overrated here its not even funny anymore.

[Hands of Iron]

Originally Posted by Flea Man

I'd like to rank him higher, but 7-10 is fair IMO.

H2H: the best bar Robinson most probably (and Leonard, begrudgingly)

Only a select few that beat him there IMO.

Could see The Keed setting a relentless pace and wearing Tommy down over 15; god knows he had the durability and chin to pull it off.

[Flea Man]

Gavilan and Rodriguez are best bets for me at 147.

[Hands of Iron]

No Robinson?!

Or did you mean in addition to? Nobody outboxes Tommy, especially over 12. Fine. I don't think Robinson would even waste his time milling around. He'll take one look at Hearns in the opposite corner be coming furiously, and with a lot more power than Hearns has ever dealt with. Those SRL flurries ain't shit

[cuchulain]

Originally Posted by Rattler

Zakman is misguided.

I will have my cookie now.

He is.


And so are you.

Both men belong on the list.

Lewis higher than Tyson.

[turbotime]

I just went through all of the lists and I gotta say good job on all of them. A lot better than a lot of expert's lists, even. Good to see my man Ike Williams getting some love at Lightweight as well

[turbotime]

No Roy Jones at 175

[WhataRock]

He came in 11th...missed the cut by 2 points.

If I had done one today I would have found a spot for him around 9 or 10...but looking at the names ahead of him..it's no real dishonour to be ranked 11th.

[turbotime]

Originally Posted by WhataRock

He came in 11th...missed the cut by 2 points.

If I had done one today I would have found a spot for him around 9 or 10...but looking at the names ahead of him..it's no real dishonour to be ranked 11th.

True. Surprised Fitzimmons made it over Roy though, to be honest.

He'd have been on there if I was around to vote!

[Hands of Iron]

Jones is such a fucking enigma. Just like Tyson, but on probably an even higher level.

I do think Mike Spinks could give him a hell of a fight at 175.

[turbotime]

Originally Posted by Hands of Iron

Jones is such a fucking enigma. Just like Tyson, but on probably an even higher level.

I do think Mike Spinks could give him a hell of a fight at 175.

Should've retired after the Tarver trilogy. There was still some sense of mystique there, now we just have noobs watching him lose at cruiserweight thinking he was never any good

I do think Spinks' height and awkwardness would have caused him a lot of problems as well. Moorer would have been another good one, he is often forgotten and he had great power and boxing skills.

[Hands of Iron]

Originally Posted by Rattler

Mike Tyson making that list is ridiculous.

Not even close.

[Hands of Iron]

Originally Posted by Foreman Hook

Nope - Jack "The Manassa Myth" Dempsey making that list is fucking ridiculous.

[japtech]

Money Team

[Rumsfeld]

Originally Posted by turbotime

I just went through all of the lists and I gotta say good job on all of them. A lot better than a lot of expert's lists, even. Good to see my man Ike Williams getting some love at Lightweight as well