Out of interest does anyone have Henderson (Ben) & Edgar in there P4P list together ?

[thewinfella]

Does anyone rank Benson and Franky P4P inside the top 10

Or do you have one or the other and why ???

[Kittikasem]

Originally Posted by thewinfella

Does anyone rank Benson and Franky P4P inside the top 10

Or do you have one or the other and why ???

I have Bendo in mine, because I had Edgar and now Bendo has beaten him twice. Thus, Edgar drops out because of two consecutive losses and Bendo moves in for two consec wins over a p4p fighter. Pretty cut and dried for me.

[Kittikasem]

I always take shit for my p4p lists of current fighters, and no doubt will do the same for this one, but here it goes anyway:

1.Anderson Silva
2.Georges St Pierre
3.Jon Jones
4.Junior dos Santos
5.Jose Aldo
6.Ben Henderson
7.Dominick Cruz
8.Dan Henderson
9.Renan Barao
10.Joseph Benavidez

Honourable mentions: Carlos Condit, Gilbert Melendez, Frankie Edgar, Lyoto Machida, Daniel Cormier, Cain Velasquez, Chael Sonnen, Gray Maynard, Martin Kampmann, Chad Mendes

[thewinfella]

Im gonna throw mine in

1. Anderson Silva
2. Georges St Pierre
3. Jon Jones
4. Jose Aldo
5. Jr dos Santos
6. Dominic Cruz
7. Lyoto Machida
8. Benson Henderson
9. Mauricio Rua
10. Renan Barao

Again i have been criticised for my lists in the past but here it is

For what its worth i have Dan Henderson #11 and Frankie Edgar #12

Do you think there's a case for both Bendo and Frankie to be inside the top 10 ?? i have to say i do

[rekcutnevets]

When/if I do a list, Edgar will be ahead of Henderson on mine. Edgar has bigger, better wins; and I thought he won last night. I don't care what the official decision was, it's my list and I get to use my winner. I don't know if they will both be in the top 10, because I haven't made my list yet.

[rekcutnevets]

Anderson Silva
GSP
Jon Jones
Jose Aldo
Junior Dos Santos
Frankie Edgar
Dominick Cruz
Gilbert Melendez
Joseph Benavidez
Renan Barao

[thewinfella]

Originally Posted by rekcutnevets

When/if I do a list, Edgar will be ahead of Henderson on mine. Edgar has bigger, better wins; and I thought he won last night. I don't care what the official decision was, it's my list and I get to use my winner. I don't know if they will both be in the top 10, because I haven't made my list yet.

Henderson is the man who beat the man

Effectively something Penn or Maynard ** couldn't do before him

** That depends on how you view them fights , I see Franky 3 & 1 (justifiably getting the nod over Penn twice IMO, i had him losing the draw against Maynard).

[greathamza]

1.Anderson Silva
2.GSP
3.Jose Aldo
4.Jon Jones
5.Junior Dos Santos
6.Dominick Cruz
7.Ben Henderson
8.Gilbert Melendez
9.Renan Barao
10.Joseph Benavidez