Which fighters between 140 and 160 would Mayweather lose to?

[haworths623]

Originally Posted by JohnAnthony

Of course Magic would win, but i didn't want to state the obvious.

I have to be honest, I have no idea who kerry hope is

He beat Proska on the Hatton-Brook undercard.

GGG beat Proska and people are saying he'd beat Mayweather now, so why not Kerry Hope?

[JohnAnthony]

also i'd be impressed if floyd were to beat any of the top 10 middleweights at the minute. floyd would be tiny compared.

[JohnAnthony]

Originally Posted by haworths623

He beat Proska on the Hatton-Brook undercard.

GGG beat Proska and people are saying he'd beat Mayweather now, so why not Kerry Hope?

fair enough, would have to watch him.

[D4thincarnation]

Originally Posted by haworths623

Which?

Fighter (% for winning)

140 lbs

Matthysse (45%)
Khan (40%)
Marquez (35%)
Gamboa (30%)

147 lbs

Pacquiao (90%)
Guererro (30%)
Brook (30%)

154 lbs

Alvarez (50 %)
Lara (65%)
Kirkland (35%)
Martinez (85%)
Golovkin (90%)


160 lbs

Martinez (95%)
Golovkin (100%)
Chavez (75%)
Pirog (70%)
Quillin (65%)

[D4thincarnation]

Originally Posted by JohnAnthony

fair enough, would have to watch him.

Proska demolished Hope in the rematch.

Hope got a wafer thin decision, an early cut affected Proska's game plan.

And Golovkin did not just beat Proska, he destroyed him

[JohnAnthony]

I like this way of doing in. Although you give way to much chance of alot of these fighters

Originally Posted by D4thincarnation

Fighter (% for winning)

140 lbs

Matthysse (45%) - 10%
Khan (40%) - 20%
Marquez (35%) - 2%
Gamboa (30%) - 10%

147 lbs

Pacquiao (90%) - 40%
Guererro (30%) - 15%
Brook (30%) - 15%

154 lbs

Alvarez (50 %) - 40%
Lara (65%) - 70% - forgot about lara
Kirkland (35%) - 40%
Martinez (85%) - 70%
Golovkin (90%) - 70%


160 lbs

Martinez (95%) - 90%
Golovkin (100%) - 90%
Chavez (75%) - Agree
Pirog (70%) - Agree
Quillin (65%) - not sure

[bigironmike]

LOL @ Amir Khan.

[Collie]

I think Mayweather has slowed a little but still would start favourite over almost everyone at 140-154 and quite even at 160.

I think Matthese would have a under-rated chance if he pressured Floyd with workrate and combinations. Pacquaio obviously has a chance but Mayweather would be favourite. As a poster above said, Golovkin and Alvarez are untested still so a little unknown but from what I've seen both would have some chance although would be underdogs in the betting (unless at 160). Martinez possibly has the best chance of beating him especially at 160. People might laugh (I don't blame them) but I would give Khan a small squeak too, I think his speed might give Mayweather problems in early rounds.

[BretN]

If you think Pacquiao has any chance against Floyd, review your life.

Martinez gives him the best fight out of the bunch

[D4thincarnation]

Originally Posted by Collie

I think Mayweather has slowed a little but still would start favourite over almost everyone at 140-154 and quite even at 160.

I think Matthese would have a under-rated chance if he pressured Floyd with workrate and combinations. Pacquaio obviously has a chance but Mayweather would be favourite. As a poster above said, Golovkin and Alvarez are untested still so a little unknown but from what I've seen both would have some chance although would be underdogs in the betting (unless at 160). Martinez possibly has the best chance of beating him especially at 160. People might laugh (I don't blame them) but I would give Khan a small squeak too, I think his speed might give Mayweather problems in early rounds.

As long as Khan doesn't get tagged by something big, he will cause Floyd lots of problems.

Khan with the right game plan and doesn't get caught by anything huge, could take it.

Floyd will have to change his style for this fight too.

If you wait on Khan, you waiting to get hit.

[BretN]

Originally Posted by D4thincarnation

Fighter (% for winning)

140 lbs

Matthysse (45%)
Khan (40%)
Marquez (35%)
Gamboa (30%)

147 lbs

Pacquiao (90%)
Guererro (30%)
Brook (30%)

154 lbs

Alvarez (50 %)
Lara (65%)
Kirkland (35%)
Martinez (85%)
Golovkin (90%)


160 lbs

Martinez (95%)
Golovkin (100%)
Chavez (75%)
Pirog (70%)
Quillin (65%)

[D4thincarnation]

Originally Posted by BretN

Deal With It!

Will Floyd prove it wrong

[JohnAnthony]

Originally Posted by Collie

I think Mayweather has slowed a little but still would start favourite over almost everyone at 140-154 and quite even at 160.

I think Matthese would have a under-rated chance if he pressured Floyd with workrate and combinations. Pacquaio obviously has a chance but Mayweather would be favourite. As a poster above said, Golovkin and Alvarez are untested still so a little unknown but from what I've seen both would have some chance although would be underdogs in the betting (unless at 160). Martinez possibly has the best chance of beating him especially at 160. People might laugh (I don't blame them) but I would give Khan a small squeak too, I think his speed might give Mayweather problems in early rounds.

Anyone who thinks Mayweather beats everyone at 160, at this stage of his career is massively overrating him.

He beat Cotto, who is a tiny 154 fighter. There are weight classes for a reason. A lot of the 160 fighters are huge and would walk through this version of maywether.

Not Martinez possibly has the best chance. I would favour every 160 fighter in the ring top 10 to beat mayweather right now.

[turbotime]

Magic Matthew Hatton
Iron Paulie Malignaggi
Kerry Hitman Hope
Rocket Randall Bailey

[oibighead]

Forget 160 fighters, he is way too small to have a chance


154 - 140 only Martinez. Pac and Alvarez have about the same chance, slim.

People like Khan and Guererro? Khan would get humiliated