Are Undefeated Reords in Boxing Impressive or Overrated?

[puga_ni_nana]

Originally Posted by bballchump11

yeah but how about you actually beat that opposition though. Nobody is calling Corley or Augustus hall of famers

so who do you rank greater, calzaghe or lewis? floyd or holyfield?
i'm not sayingit's bad to go undefeated but it's the oppositions that matters and nevermind if you lost a couple of ones on the way.

[Bogotazo]

Both.

[bballchump11]

Originally Posted by puga_ni_nana

so who do you rank greater, calzaghe or lewis? floyd or holyfield?
i'm not sayingit's bad to go undefeated but it's the oppositions that matters and nevermind if you lost a couple of ones on the way.

It's obviously a combination of the two. But the question here is going undefeated impressive and of course it is. How can winning all your fights not be impressive.

Chavez went 86-0 at one point in his career. That's impressive as phuck no matter what anybody says

Originally Posted by Run It

good point. if it was based soley on who you fought, Ricardo Mayorga would be a top 100 ATG

exactly man Judah would be up there too

[puga_ni_nana]

Originally Posted by bballchump11

It's obviously a combination of the two. But the question here is going undefeated impressive and of course it is. How can winning all your fights not be impressive.

Chavez went 86-0 at one point in his career. That's impressive as phuck no matter what anybody says



exactly man Judah would be up there too

it's ok but not too impressive. otherwise, chavez jr (when he's still undefeated) wouldbe seen as a future ATG already.