Randall 'Tex' Cobb. The undisputed best chin ever?

[MrBumboclart]

Agree or disagree?

I can't see how he isn't. The beating he took off Holmes was inhuman. He summed it up himself at the end of the bout when asked if would want a rematch 'Yeah, but I doubt Larry's hands could take it.'

Not to mention he also fought Shavers and not once appeared shook.

His only KO loss was from a cut I believe?

[Bill1234]

Hard to say...

I would say Chuvalo did for the sheer number of huge punchers he faced without going down.

DeJohn, Williams, Frazier, Foreman, Bonavena, Mathis, Quarry, and Patterson were all guys that could really whack, and all failed to deck Chuvalo.

[The Kurgan]

Chuvalo, McCall and Cobb are pretty much indistinguishable in terms of how rock-hard their chins were.

[MrBumboclart]

Originally Posted by The Kurgan

Chuvalo, McCall and Cobb are pretty much indistinguishable in terms of how rock-hard their chins were.

Yeah I think there is a certain extent of toughess you can reach and it's impossible to rank the fellas at that level. You just CANNOT knock Chuvalo, McCall and Cobb out using fists - it can't happen. I guess it's impossible to rank those kinds of guys.

[clinikill]

I saw Cobb get knocked down by journeyman Eddie Gregg in their match. Tex also got knocked out in the first round by tomato can Dee Collier. I haven't seen the fight, but according to various observers, it was a legitimate KO.

McCall and Chuvalo have better claims to the title than Cobb, in my opinion.

[Bill1234]

Originally Posted by clinikill

I saw Cobb get knocked down by journeyman Eddie Gregg in their match. Tex also got knocked out in the first round by tomato can Dee Collier. I haven't seen the fight, but according to various observers, it was a legitimate KO.

McCall and Chuvalo have better claims to the title than Cobb, in my opinion.

I believe around that time Cobb was also partying far harder than he was training and fighting, so it's likely Cobb was far from his usual durable self at the point of the Collier fight.

[red cobra]

Originally Posted by clinikill

I saw Cobb get knocked down by journeyman Eddie Gregg in their match. Tex also got knocked out in the first round by tomato can Dee Collier. I haven't seen the fight, but according to various observers, it was a legitimate KO.

McCall and Chuvalo have better claims to the title than Cobb, in my opinion.

It's possible that Tex just stayed around after that chin lost it's magical powers. He just hung around too lon. The same might have happened to Chuvalo if he didn't quit when he did. Jake LaMotta finally got put on the deck by Danny Nardico, and that was because he syated after the expiration date on his chin went out. I don't know about McCall, but I'm sure that the law of averages will take it's toll on him too if he stays active too long.

[fists of fury]

I think Ray Mercer should be added to the list. Granite chin.

[The Funny Man 7]

I'll dispute it if we're talking pound for pound. Pound for pound I'd rank the following over Cobb or Chuvalo:

Juan Laporte
Gerry Penalosa
Billy Graham
Carmen Basilio
Jake Lamotta
Ben Tackie

I think its too close tocall at heavyweight between Chuvalo, McCall, and Cobb.

[Manning]

This fella isn't half underrated.

[dyna]

Wach can also take plenty of powershots from a much harder hitter than Wlad.

[Surf-Bat]

George Chuvalo and Battling Nelson are the first two I think of.

[CANNONBALL]

Originally Posted by clinikill

I saw Cobb get knocked down by journeyman Eddie Gregg in their match. Tex also got knocked out in the first round by tomato can Dee Collier. I haven't seen the fight, but according to various observers, it was a legitimate KO.

McCall and Chuvalo have better claims to the title than Cobb, in my opinion.

1. Collier, tho no world beater, was no "tomato can"

2. I too have never seen the fight, but have heard rumours that Tex may have gone into the tank

3. Mcall the toughest at HW for me

[Titan1]

Originally Posted by The Funny Man 7

I'll dispute it if we're talking pound for pound. Pound for pound I'd rank the following over Cobb or Chuvalo:

Juan Laporte
Gerry Penalosa
Billy Graham
Carmen Basilio
Jake Lamotta
Ben Tackie

I think its too close tocall at heavyweight between Chuvalo, McCall, and Cobb.

Laporte was floored in one of his last several fights.I think Chuvalo wins out over McCall, and Cobb.

[Surf-Bat]

Originally Posted by CANNONBALL

1. Collier, tho no world beater, was no "tomato can"

2. I too have never seen the fight, but have heard rumours that Tex may have gone into the tank

3. Mcall the toughest at HW for me

I saw it. Tex may have. Or maybe his drinking finally caught up with him