Now who's the leader of their generation: Pacquiao or Mayweather?

[BagsWithDust]

Originally Posted by slugger3000

Manny Pacquiao without a doubt... Mr. Feathers has hand picked all his fights and he fights once every 15 months! Void is a hype job...

Pacquiao and arum have hand picked their fights too....

[Bill Butcher]

Originally Posted by Asterion

Even though he has arguably lost the last three fights, Pacman still has the better resume.

But Mayweather is undefeated and would probably school Pac.

Who's the best of that generation?

Neither of them, the 3 Mexicans are the greatest of the generation (Morales, Marquez & Barrera) Those guys did there thing in the ring, not outside it.

[jeffjoiner]

Originally Posted by Stinky gloves

Calzaghe 47-0 >>> Floyd

Floyd's win over Hernandez >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Anything on Slappy's resume.

[Toontoon]

It's always been Mayweather, history will show this too when the fan boys are gone.

[Manos de Hierro]

Originally Posted by Bill Butcher

Neither of them, the 3 Mexicans are the greatest of the generation (Barrera, Morales & Marquez) Those guys did there thing in the ring, not outside it.

Fixed.

[jawbreaker]

Originally Posted by janeschicken

You mean like Ortiz did?
You mean like Guerrero does?

The difference is those guys don't expect to get half the money.

The only reason to fight Pac would be the money, so if that guy moving up wants half the money he can take his business else where.

The only thing Floyd is quilty of is making sure he got the best deal available and controlling his on destiny.

[Sunchild78]

It's obvious. Floyd has been on top since he became champion. He's well rounded and more skilled then Pac ever was.

[Nonito Smoak]

Originally Posted by Toontoon

It's always been Mayweather, history will show this too when the fan boys are gone.

X 2

Been saying this for 2 years. I'm extremely confident in my belief, too.

Originally Posted by jeffjoiner

Floyd's win over Hernandez >>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Anything on Slappy's resume.

This.

Genaro is a beast win. Don't care if he was old and it was his last fight. Undefeated at 130. Top 10 easily all time at 130. Great win.

[Box702]

Neither,They are 2 media created phonys.2 most overrated boxers of all time.Floyd/pac are good but carefully managed to look unbeatable.Marquez is a great role model & example of fighting the best with no excuses.A humble warrior.

[Alo2006]

Mayweather is the best of this generation. A true boxing fan knows this! we wouldn't be having this conversation if they fought because it would be even clear. People are saying Pac resume is better base on more names, but catch weight flaws his resume. He had advantages against all the ww he fought!

[TheWolf]

Floyd

[mr. piff]

Originally Posted by pugilistspecialist

Gatti just had beat ward twice and Branco for the belt. Fights many had on the biggest stage his opponents took bad beatings or hadn't won in a while
You gotta be digging real hard considering everyone knew Bruxelles was a time up fight as was Mitchell at new weights Judah did lose but get koed or take severe beatings like Hatton cotton

It's a well known fact Floyd was to fight judah for the belts before he lost to Baldomir.

Don't know why "objective" posters never post the circumstances surrounding and leading up to a bout.

And yes, the time when you fight them, is just as important as the name, and how far removed are they when they made that name mean something.

[mr. piff]

Originally Posted by Box702

Neither,They are 2 media created phonys.2 most overrated boxers of all time.Floyd/pac are good but carefully managed to look unbeatable.Marquez is a great role model & example of fighting the best with no excuses.A humble warrior.

Don't fully understand that statement, when one went on to dominate every fighter he faced with their varying styles, and the other one just about, with the exception of dominating skilled technicians

[Nonito Smoak]

Originally Posted by Box702

Neither,They are 2 media created phonys.2 most overrated boxers of all time.Floyd/pac are good but carefully managed to look unbeatable.Marquez is a great role model & example of fighting the best with no excuses.A humble warrior.

So.... Pacquiao/Casamayor/Diaz X2/Salido/Katsidis/Gainer/Barrera/(huge drop off) are better fighters than the guys on Pac and May's resume?

You literally wanting to do the "List their 12 best wins" thing?

[Juiceboxbiotch]

Still Pacquiao. He stepped up, fought the best, and beat the best...except for the one who wouldn't fight.