GSP: Is he the second greatest MMA fight ever?

[Rob_Floyd]

Oh, yeah, Fedor never held the Strikeforce title. We should probably keep our facts straight, here. I mean, we are all experts.

[BobDigi5060]

Originally Posted by Rob_Floyd

That's true. Sure, he was tapped out after winning that belt, but it was in Pride, not Cage Rage. You got him there.

And we got UFC Gold for the SF Title, just call it even when it comes to which Title.

[BobDigi5060]

Originally Posted by Rob_Floyd

Oh, yeah, Fedor never held the Strikeforce title. We should probably keep our facts straight, here. I mean, we are all experts.

You misunderstood somehow. Your right, he did have it, but he lost it. Y'all musta forgot.

[Stoo]

Originally Posted by BobDigi5060

My man stoo already believes he's the most talented, that's a step in the right direction.

Please dont bring up a point I made earlier in the thread which you failed miserably to understand when I posted it to back up your quite frankly weird and contradictory rambling later in a thread that you said at least 3 times now you were going to stop posting in

Thanks x

[Stoo]

Originally Posted by BobDigi5060

You misunderstood somehow. Your right, he did have it, but he lost it. Y'all musta forgot.

****s sake

[BobDigi5060]

Originally Posted by Stoo

Please dont bring up a point I made earlier in the thread which you failed miserably to understand when I posted it to back up your quite frankly weird and contradictory rambling later in a thread that you said at least 3 times now you were going to stop posting in

Thanks x

It's crazy shit like "He lost to better fighters" that I can't ignore.... Fedor lost to Hendo bro, just crazy shit, crazy ways of looking at things that some posters have. It has nothing to do with you, but it's nice to see some words for a change rather than some cheerleading with smileys.

[Rob_Floyd]

Originally Posted by BobDigi5060

You misunderstood somehow. Your right, he did have it, but he lost it. Y'all musta forgot.

Except...he didn't.

[greathamza]

Originally Posted by Rob_Floyd

Do you know what the word "resume" means?

Damn Rob never thought youd crack me up like that

[greathamza]

Bob mmath doesnt work
Sure Andy beat Hendo and Hendo beat Fedor but it doesnt mean that if Fedor and Andy fought that Andy would win

[BobDigi5060]

Originally Posted by greathamza

Bob mmath doesnt work
Sure Andy beat Hendo and Hendo beat Fedor but it doesnt mean that if Fedor and Andy fought that Andy would win

I don't know what your talking about, but that's not what I was driving at.

[BobDigi5060]

Originally Posted by Rob_Floyd

Except...he didn't.

Oh he never held the SF Title, I see. That's not a knock either.

[Beekeeper]

I just want to use this moment of confusion to point out that Aoki twice beat Kikuchi who beat Jake Shields who beat Okami who beat Spider who through another complicated process has beaten Fedor.

So once again, it is Aoki who really comes out on top

[CrimsonBeast]

I consider Silva the GOAT at the moment. He is destroying people while the new breed of MMA fighters are making old legends seem one dimensional. Hell, silva moved up a weight class and destroyed people there. GSP can't end fights in his own weight class .

Both cleared their divisions but, Silva did most of it while toying with his opposition. GSP had to work his ass off. Also, I think we can all agree Silva has a better chance at beating Jon Jones than GSP has at beating Silva.

[Haggis McJackass]

Originally Posted by CrimsonBeast

I consider Silva the GOAT at the moment. He is destroying people while the new breed of MMA fighters are making old legends seem one dimensional. Hell, silva moved up a weight class and destroyed people there. GSP can't end fights in his own weight class .

Both cleared their divisions but, Silva did most of it while toying with his opposition. GSP had to work his ass off. Also, I think we can all agree Silva has a better chance at beating Jon Jones than GSP has at beating Silva.

Silva's style lends itself to more highlight-reel knockouts. The fighting style he's had from the start is more flashy - GSP is more of a grinder.

But GSP hasn't really had to "work his ass off" in his fights. I mean, the guy has barely lost a round for half a decade. He could certainly finish more, but it's not like GSP is turning in Benson-Edgar type decision victories. He pitches shutouts.

[Ne5ville14]

Originally Posted by BobDigi5060

Cage Rage, about as significant as Fedor's SF Title. It's not like he was tapping out and losing that Title way back when either.



It is, and a silly thing to say. Absolutely silly. Lost to better competition? Anderson Silva beat a man Fedor lost to.

Common man, If I were you, I would just stop right there...wich I'm going to do TBH...


The batshit crazy stuff I can read on this forum....

Fedor won the SF HW belt...rolf...

Cage Rage title same thing as the SF title....