ATG Acid Test: Mayweather, Jr vs. Chavez, Sr.

[NWS]

Who do you rate higher?

Floyd Mayweather, Jr
Record: 43-0-0 (26) / Peak: 43-0-0 (26)

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo (x2)
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley

Julio Cesar Chavez, Sr
Record: 107-6-2 (86) / Peak: 87-0-0 (72)

Meldrick Taylor (x2)
Edwin Rosario
Jose Luis Ramirez
Hector Camacho
Rocky Lockridge
Roger Mayweather (x2)
Mario Martinez

[MVC]

JR. Way more dominant, 17 year stretch
3 time lineal champ
8 time world champion
5 different weight classes
Beat more HOF/ATGS

SR Lost to Whitaker/ODLH
Beat CAB drivers for most of his career
Good wins on Taylor though.

[NWS]

I'd say Meldrick Taylor and Edwin Rosario were both more formidable and dangerous opponents on the night JCC fought them than anybody Floyd has, although he's spread a lot of quality from 130-154.

[bronx]

Floyd ain't there yet he might never be unless he does something special

Beat Sexy Sergio

Or Canelo and Trout

if not then he ain't making it that high up sorry

[MVC]

Originally Posted by NWS

I'd say Meldrick Taylor and Edwin Rosario were both more formidable and dangerous opponents on the night JCC fought them than anybody Floyd has, although he's spread a lot of quality from 130-154.

How is Meldrick Taylor more dangerous and formidable than an undefeated Corrales, ODLH, Genaro, Cotto (154), among MANY others

Taylor at the time when he fought JCC had 1 decent victory, and that was vs Buddy.

[Scar]

Mayweather by UD.

[bronx]

Originally Posted by MVC

JR. Way more dominant, 17 year stretch
3 time lineal champ
8 time world champion
5 different weight classes
Beat more HOF/ATGS

SR Lost to Whitaker/ODLH
Beat CAB drivers for most of his career
Good wins on Taylor though.

Chavez was the truth

YDKSAB in the late 80's and early 90's you little young ass ni99a!

GTFOH

Floyd ain't there yet he should fought Pac when he had a chance

he fucked up and I like Floyd I am a huge fan

[MVC]

Originally Posted by Scar

Mayweather by UD.

Wide Wide UD

[MVC]

Originally Posted by bronx

Chavez was the truth

YDKSAB in the late 80's and early 90's you little young ass ni99a!

GTFOH

Floyd ain't there yet he should fought Pac when he had a chance

he fucked up and I like Floyd I am a huge fan

Shut up dumbass, you know nothing about boxing.

Omg JCC SR beat Cab Drivers/Pizza deliverers. Let's call him the greatest of all time.

Fail Thread.

[bronx]

Originally Posted by Scar

Mayweather by UD.

rated not who would win

don't be so sure though at 135 Chavez was awesome too

but so was Floyd I know

[MVC]

Originally Posted by bronx

rated not who would win

don't be so sure though at 135 Chavez was awesome too

but so was Floyd I know

Floyd. You don't know shit about boxing, son.

[The_Destroyer]

Floyd.

Chavez, Sr.??? the fraud?

[MVC]

Originally Posted by The_Destroyer

Floyd.

Chavez, Sr.??? the fraud?

[AZ_40]

This is a question in which I could say Floyd right now then Chavez in 2 hours

[MVC]

Originally Posted by AZ_40

This is a question in which I could say Floyd right now then Chavez in 2 hours

But then you come to your senses and realize "What was I thinking?"

Then you'd say Floyd again.