Edgar beat Aldo on my card

[sugarngold]

Richard Steele.

[slugger3000]

I had it 4-1 Aldo... Aldo won easily. I find it funny that Frankie wins one round and he competes in a few more and everyone screams robbery! What a fucking joke.. Everytime Frankie makes a fight close people claim he won.. Bullshit! Let me tell you what Frankie is good at. When he fights an elite fighter, he is good at losing a close fight.. He's good at not getting his ass whooped!

[PivotPunch]

No Aldo won clearly I like Edgar but Aldo won for sure even if Edgar won 1-2rounds

[El Bujia]

Aldo is clearly a more skilled/talented fighter. He just needs to work on his cardio. When he was fresh he was on another level to Frankie, who was unable to do anything. But then it's a 5 round fight, and stamina is a big part of the fight game.

I had Aldo winning the first 3.

[turbotime]

Originally Posted by rekcutnevets

Oscar

You like Oscar


Aldo 3-2 pretty clearly.

[Haggis McJackass]

Aldo the first 3, Frankie the last 2. Pretty clear in my book.

[elmaldito]

edgar clear as day won round 3. It was his best round. Round 4 and 5 aldo was gassed and did nothing. Edgar won 3 to 2. I knew they were gonna screw him because they didnt show any edgar highlights. Edgar clearly outlanded him bad in 3 4 and 5.

[elmaldito]

Originally Posted by Haggis McJackass

Aldo the first 3, Frankie the last 2. Pretty clear in my book.

how does aldo win round 3? He landed one nice kick. Edgar had his best round in 3.

[Haggis McJackass]

Originally Posted by elmaldito

how does aldo win round 3? He landed one nice kick. Edgar had his best round in 3.

I was drunk when I watched the fight, so I admittedly might need to rewatch it as I didn't keep a running scorecard. But Edgar didn't cause any damage that I recall. He was always responding to Aldo's movements, was unable to hold his ground, and was generally doing enough to be competitive without doing enough to win the round.

Aldo wasn't following him around aimlessly, he was pressing the action. He landed the best shot of the round (and the fight) in round 3, and he was never taken outside of his comfort zone.

Edgar didn't get blown out of the water, but he didn't control the tempo of the fight either. He buzzed around, tried to avoid Aldo's strikes, and landed several meaningless shots that didn't seem to affect Aldo at all.

[Beouche]

Originally Posted by Haggis McJackass

I was drunk when I watched the fight, so I admittedly might need to rewatch it as I didn't keep a running scorecard. But Edgar didn't cause any damage that I recall. He was always responding to Aldo's movements, was unable to hold his ground, and was generally doing enough to be competitive without doing enough to win the round.

Aldo wasn't following him around aimlessly, he was pressing the action. He landed the best shot of the round (and the fight) in round 3, and he was never taken outside of his comfort zone.

Edgar didn't get blown out of the water, but he didn't control the tempo of the fight either. He buzzed around, tried to avoid Aldo's strikes, and landed several meaningless shots that didn't seem to affect Aldo at all.

The 3rd round is what is causing the contention

There was no "clear winner" of that round - just check out the posts in here - its totally split

[Rob_Floyd]

I seem to recall the 4th being Frankie's clearest and best round.

[Haggis McJackass]

Originally Posted by Beouche

The 3rd round is what is causing the contention

There was no "clear winner" of that round - just check out the posts in here - its totally split

I don't recall Edgar landing any clean strikes that really got Aldo's attention or caused a reaction from me or my friends. Aldo's kick to the face certainly did.

I also don't recall Edgar taking ground away from Aldo, forcing him to move anywhere he didn't want to move.

I remember a lot of movement from Edgar, but not much constructive aggression. Not much in the way of making Aldo uncomfortable.

Like I said, I remember the round being competitive, but I remember at the time turning to my friend and saying "3-0 Aldo", and he responded "yep."

Though, again as I said, I was drunk and haven't rewatched the fight.

[Haggis McJackass]

Originally Posted by Rob_Floyd

I seem to recall the 4th being Frankie's clearest and best round.

[Beouche]

Originally Posted by Haggis McJackass

I don't recall Edgar landing any clean strikes that really got Aldo's attention or caused a reaction from me or my friends. Aldo's kick to the face certainly did.

I also don't recall Edgar taking ground away from Aldo, forcing him to move anywhere he didn't want to move.

I remember a lot of movement from Edgar, but not much constructive aggression. Not much in the way of making Aldo uncomfortable.

Like I said, I remember the round being competitive, but I remember at the time turning to my friend and saying "3-0 Aldo", and he responded "yep."

Though, again as I said, I was drunk and haven't rewatched the fight.

Sure man

Of course round 4 was Frankies best - R3 was contentious, round 5 was pretty close too

R1 and 2 Aldo destroyed

What shocked me was how much bigger Aldo was in there. It looked like he was in a different weight class

[chimba]

Edgar won 4 and 5. 3 is arguable, I gave it to Aldo.

Edgars downfall is his lack of power. He will never ever win close fights unfortunately.