How did YOU score the Pacquiao Marquez Quadrilogy?

[BoxingKangaroo]

Originally Posted by JDK

3-0-1 for Marquez.
I still see many giving the 2nd fight to Manny which seems strange. That's by far the easiest to score for Marquez. I guess the difference in opinion/judging is why all fights seem pretty close.
Bogotazo, I may be thinking of a diff. round, but you gave the eight round of the second fight to Manny? He took huge damage during that round more so than any other round if I'm thinking correctly.

i think the 3rd is the easiest to score for marquez....

[Beouche]

1 and 2 are pick ems

3 and 4 are not


it has to be either....

4-0 JMM
3-1 JMM
2-2


There can be no other honest result

[PetethePrince]

Originally Posted by Bogotazo

No, I have it 7-5 Marquez, which is more like 7-6 with the knockdown. If you score round 7 even, it becomes 114-114.

Round 7 isn't the knockdown round, wouldn't that make it a 114-113 for Marquez? Yes, a 6-5-1 would make it 114-114.

*Edit* Reading comprehension failure on my part. My bad. I thought you meant if Pac won that round the fight would be even but you mean it's an even round at best. If I remember correctly round 7 is that controversial round but I like you had Marquez definitely edging it.

[PhillyPhan69]

I voted 3-1, but scored it 3-0-1..But that was not an option!

[bjl12]

Originally Posted by Beouche

it has to be either....

4-0 JMM
3-1 JMM
3-0-1 JMM

There can be no other honest result

Fixed.

[Beouche]

Originally Posted by Bogotazo

I usually score the first fight for Marquez, by a point, occasionally two. Being generous to Pac, I've scored it a draw.

The second fight I always give to Marquez by a point, with round 7 being the closest swing round. I've memorized that fight at this point. Round 1 Manny wins on activity, though Marquez lands the best single right hand of the round. Round 2 is Marquez's, that's when he lands his famous 3-punch combination as Pac is mid air. 3rd round is the knockdown round. 4th and 5th is Manny's. In the 6th Marquez has him on a string, his most dominant round. 7 is the headbutt round, very close, Marquez nicks it for me, wouldn't have a problem scoring it even (making the fight a draw). 8th is Manny's, 9th Marquez again has him on a string, 10th Manny lands that overhand left that stuns him as Marquez comes forward, and I think Marquez nicks the championship rounds, 11 and 12. 7-5 Marquez.

The 3rd I have a few even rounds in the first 4, they go back and fourth, and Manny wins the 12th, and maybe one other round (the 7th?) In any case I scored it for Marquez by four or five points. Many rounds were close, but not the fight itself.

The 4th obviously doesn't need any scorecards. The judges had Marquez behind by a point, which means they gave him the first 2 rounds, which I gave to Manny when watching live out of expecting the worst, and he may have deserved them anyway, close rounds.

Spot on as usual Bogo

[Villain]

Here is a better poll for you. How many ESB members can OBJECTIVELY score a Pac vs JMM fight. I'd say about 5% tops.

Such obvious hate.

[Bogotazo]

Originally Posted by PetethePrince

Round 7 isn't the knockdown round, wouldn't that make it a 114-113 for Marquez? Yes, a 6-5-1 would make it 114-114.

*Edit* Reading comprehension failure on my part. My bad. I thought you meant if Pac won that round the fight would be even but you mean it's an even round at best. If I remember correctly round 7 is that controversial round but I like you had Marquez definitely edging it.

Right

[JDK]

Originally Posted by Bogotazo

I'm pretty sure you're either thinking about 6 or 9.

Just got in from the gym.
Checked the second fight and no way that 8th round goes to Manny. In fact, a little more and he could've folded. Marquez landed on that body and caused almost the same reaction Manny got from Margarito.. hands low and all. Manny came to his corner in low spirits once the round ended.
I'm certain you're thinking of a different round.
Hilariously pathetic how two of the judges gave that round to Pacman
Anyway, 2nd fight easy to score. First and third not so much.

[Bogotazo]

Originally Posted by JDK

Just got in from the gym.
Checked the second fight and no way that 8th round goes to Manny. In fact, a little more and he could've folded. Marquez landed on that body and caused almost the same reaction Manny got from Margarito.. hands low and all. Manny came to his corner in low spirits once the round ended.
I'm certain you're thinking of a different round.
Hilariously pathetic how two of the judges gave that round to Pacman
Anyway, 2nd fight easy to score. First and third not so much.

Just re-watched, your right. I mixed up the 9th with the 8th.

Damn that was an extremely punishing round. I don't even remember it being so brutal, Manny was backing off for the entire round.

[JDK]

Originally Posted by Bogotazo

Just re-watched, your right. I mixed up the 9th with the 8th.

Damn that was an extremely punishing round. I don't even remember it being so brutal, Manny was backing off for the entire round.

And yet 2 judges score it 10-9 for Manny
That body shot Marquez landed from so far away did it all.

[ChampionsForever]

This Bogo guy is great! Slamming anybody he thinks is biased towards Pac yet he is OBVIOUSLY biased towards Marquez. How can you expect people to watch the fights objectively when you cant yourself?.

[eze]

3-1 Marquez.

[Bogotazo]

Originally Posted by JDK

And yet 2 judges score it 10-9 for Manny
That body shot Marquez landed from so far away did it all.

Word. What's weird is that two judges also gave Manny the 6th, the only other round that's nearly as dominant for Marquez. Makes absolutely no sense.

Originally Posted by ChampionsForever

This Bogo guy is great! Slamming anybody he thinks is biased towards Pac yet he is OBVIOUSLY biased towards Marquez. How can you expect people to watch the fights objectively when you cant yourself?.

There's a difference between being a fan and being biased. My scores reflect the competitiveness of each fight, and are consistent with the majority opinion. The Pactards, however, are in a world of their own.

[Farmboxer]

Pac was winning, Marquez was almost stopped, but Pac got careless and Marquez' steroid expert strength trainer really won the fight for him. They need to get steroids out of boxing, get better testing as Marquez' strength trainer was also the best at showing athletes how to cheat on the drug tests. The trainer even exposed his fellow steroid experts!

3-1 Pac