Create the best P4P fighter of all time (Not Ray Robinson or Willie Pep)

[Bill1234]

Assets:

Hand speed/reflexes: Jones Jr
Power: Julian Jackson
Chin: Hagler or Chuvalo
Work rate: Armstrong
Stamina: Marciano
Footwork: Ali
Defence: Toney
Mentality: Gatti
Heart: Gatti

Punches:

Jab: Holmes
Right Cross: Hearns
Overhand right: Julian Jackson
Left hook: Frazier
Uppercut: Tyson
Right hook: Holmes

[JohnThomas1]

Thomas Hearns with Haglers chin, Armstrongs stamina and Benitez's ability to see punches.

[brownpimp88]

Pernell Whitaker with ko power is virtually an unstoppable fighter.

[NickHudson]

I too like Hearns as a basic blueprint, with a few modifications as you have highlighted here JT1.

Another modification would be a sturdier (thicker) midsection...

Originally Posted by JohnThomas1

Thomas Hearns with Haglers chin, Armstrongs stamina and Benitez's ability to see punches.

[JohnThomas1]

Originally Posted by NickHudson

I too like Hearns as a basic blueprint, with a few modifications as you have highlighted here JT1.

Another modification would be a sturdier (thicker) midsection...

Hahaha, fair enough mate. I always thought his ability to take a body punch (or non ability) was a bit exaggerated. Truth be told i'm not convinced Ray's body attack in fight 1 was as much a defining factor as the media made out.

[Manassa]

Originally Posted by Bill1234

Assets:

Hand speed/reflexes: Jones Jr
Power: Julian Jackson
Chin: Hagler or Chuvalo
Work rate: Armstrong
Stamina: Marciano
Footwork: Ali
Defence: Toney
Mentality: Gatti
Heart: Gatti

Punches:

Jab: Holmes
Right Cross: Hearns
Overhand right: Julian Jackson
Left hook: Frazier
Uppercut: Tyson
Right hook: Holmes

For the last time, Bill, it doesn't work like that. I'll give you an example; a fighter cannot possess the uppercut of Tyson and the cross of Hearns. Tyson's uppercut was so good because he had short, powerful arms and a low centre of gravity that allowed him to generate great torque and momentum through his hips. A fighter of Hearns' stature wouldn't just be able to pull a Tyson uppercut out of the bag, it would have to be of a different kind. Just like Tyson wouldn't be able to produce the long-armed leverage of Hearns. Further, can you really imagine a fighter having the mentality of Gatti but getting on his bike and jabbing like an Ali-Holmes hybrid? While somehow working just as hard as Armstrong? It's a ridiculous concept. Your fighter would look like Krusty the Klown.

[Robbi]

Originally Posted by Manassa

For the last time, Bill, it doesn't work like that. I'll give you an example; a fighter cannot possess the uppercut of Tyson and the cross of Hearns. Tyson's uppercut was so good because he had short, powerful arms and a low centre of gravity that allowed him to generate great torque and momentum through his hips. A fighter of Hearns' stature wouldn't just be able to pull a Tyson uppercut out of the bag, it would have to be of a different kind. Just like Tyson wouldn't be able to produce the long-armed leverage of Hearns. Further, can you really imagine a fighter having the mentality of Gatti but getting on his bike and jabbing like an Ali-Holmes hybrid? While somehow working just as hard as Armstrong? It's a ridiculous concept. Your fighter would look like Krusty the Klown.

Its only fun and fantasy, so he rates the best fighter in each selected category, thus creating a perfect fighter. I'm sure everyone with half a brain can see someone with Ali's boxing ability and Gatti's mentality doesn't quite add up.

His thread heading doesn't add up to his own awnsers in the first post. What he really means is select the best fighter in each category, as this is backed up with his own awnser. Stamina, right hand, footwork, heart, jab, etc.

[Manassa]

Originally Posted by Robbi

Its only fun and fantasy, so he rates the best fighter in each selected category, thus creating a perfect fighter. I'm sure everyone with half a brain can see someone with Ali's boxing ability and Gatti's mentality doesn't quite add up.

His thread heading doesn't add up to his own awnsers in the first post. What he really means is select the best fighter in each category, as this is backed up with his own awnser. Stamina, right hand, footwork, heart, jab, etc.

Yes, it is best to change the title to 'best fighters in these categories...'

[Robbi]

Originally Posted by Manassa

Yes, it is best to change the title to 'best fighters in these categories...'

Id like to see this fighter being created. He'd have adjustable arms and height. He'd change from 5' 5" up to 6' 1" between rounds. Change of technique in a matter of seconds. Suddenly crude wide hooks like Marciano, then within the blink of an eye straight punches down the middle resembling Ali.

[India_Foot_Bob]

Joe Calzaghe, except with Bernard Hopkins' heart, boxing skill, power, speed, reflexes, athleticism, body, and name -fullstop-

[teeto]

Originally Posted by Bill1234

Assets:

Hand speed/reflexes: Jones Jr
Power: Julian Jackson
Chin: Hagler or Chuvalo
Work rate: Armstrong
Stamina: Marciano
Footwork: Ali
Defence: Toney
Mentality: Gatti
Heart: Gatti

Punches:

Jab: Holmes
Right Cross: Hearns
Overhand right: Julian Jackson
Left hook: Frazier
Uppercut: Tyson
Right hook: Holmes

I always thought Roberto Duran had the best style (at his best), going forward at his opponent and being so defensively sound while doing so. He'd weave and duck shots, while landing uppercuts and hooks all the while. James Toney and others could stand in front of a guy and not get hit, using angles and ringcraft, but Duran was landing counters at the same time which could finish the fight, the best blend of offense and defense I've ever seen. And he never wound up his shots or telegraph them, he'd just slip in with a right cross with max power in it.

I f we're gonna do this in the format set here though, I think:

hand speed - Ali
power - trinidad/tyson
work rate - pryor/armstrong
strength - chavez
chin - lamotta/mcullough
stamina - pryor
footwork - robinson / benny leonard
defense - pep
heart - too hard to pick! but, gatti
reflexes - benitez

punches :

jab - Holmes
right cross - hearns
left hook - frazier
uppercut - tyson
right hook - dempsey

Let me know what ypu think

[Jbuz]

Roy Jones with the chin of Hagler, and heart of Frazier. And this is coming from someone who is a critic of Jones (though I'm a big fan outside ESB).

[Holmes' Jab]

Hand speed: Patterson
Power: Shavers
Work rate: Hagler
Strength: Lewis
Chin: McCall
Stamina: Marciano
Footwork: SRL
Defense: Whitaker
Heart: Frazier
Reflexes: Ali

Punches:

Jab: Holmes
Right cross: Louis
Left hook: Tyson
Uppercut: Bowe
Right hook: Foreman

[ChrisPontius]

Originally Posted by Manassa

For the last time, Bill, it doesn't work like that. I'll give you an example; a fighter cannot possess the uppercut of Tyson and the cross of Hearns. Tyson's uppercut was so good because he had short, powerful arms and a low centre of gravity that allowed him to generate great torque and momentum through his hips. A fighter of Hearns' stature wouldn't just be able to pull a Tyson uppercut out of the bag, it would have to be of a different kind. Just like Tyson wouldn't be able to produce the long-armed leverage of Hearns. Further, can you really imagine a fighter having the mentality of Gatti but getting on his bike and jabbing like an Ali-Holmes hybrid? While somehow working just as hard as Armstrong? It's a ridiculous concept. Your fighter would look like Krusty the Klown.

Right, and what's more, you can't have Toney/Whitakers defence with Hearns' punching power. Anyone who thinks that's possible doesn't understand boxing.

[Bill Butcher]

Erik Morales with Ali`s speed of hand & foot + whitaker`s defence, now thats 1 hell of a fighter.