Dan Rafael had it 6-0, Taylor

[RDJ]

I had it 4 rounds to 2 in favor of Taylor.

Ps. Best avatar I've seen in a while:

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/...atar2216_1.gif

[Brickhaus]

Originally Posted by brooklyn1550

1 Pavlik 10-9
2 Taylor 10-8
3 Pavlik 10-9
4 Pavlik 10-9
5 Taylor 10-9
6 Pavlik 10-9

How could you score the first round for Pavlik? Rest of it I had the same as you, although I thought rounds 4 - 6 could have leigitmately gone either way. 1 + 2 were clearly Taylor and 3 was clearly Pavlik though, IMHO.

Rafael's not much at scoring. He's very useful with rumors and is good at factual reporting, but doesn't have a great eye for a lot of what goes on in the ring.

[Marnoff]

Fire this reject.

[psychopath]

Well, I have it for Taylor too.

Here's my score card:

1 Pavlik 10-9
2 Taylor 10-8
3 Pavlik 10-9
4 Taylor 10-9
5 Taylor 10-9
6 Pavlik 10-9

[Carlos Primera]

i had taylor by a point.

[Cruiser1]

Originally Posted by sues2nd

The majority of the posters on this site had it for Taylor as well. Tho not by a shutout.

Go look....there is a poll.

Dan Raphael is a decent boxing writer who tends to play favorites at times. But he is nothing more than decent at best. Try not to pay too much mind to him....

What does that tell u about the majority of the posters on this site then? I had Pavlik up 4-2 after 6. He was raking Taylor with those right hands all night. Taylor was offering up little flurries here and there but Pavlik was doing the more steady work.

[nervousxtian]

Originally Posted by RDJ

I had it 4 rounds to 2 in favor of Taylor.

Ps. Best avatar I've seen in a while:

http://www.eastsideboxing.com/forum/...atar2216_1.gif

Thanks!

[rodney]

What does that tell you.?
It tells you that he had a dick up his mouth.

[Cruiser1]

For What It's Worth, Rafael Had Ruiz Beating Toney 7-5.

[swedeone]

1. Pavlik 10-9
2. Taylor 10-8
3. Pavlik 10-9
4. EVEN 10-10
5. Taylor 10-9
6. Pavlik 10-9

57-57 DEAD EVEN going into the 7th on my card. I have watched the fight 3 times now and could easily see it being 57-56 someone going into the 7th. Anyone that had Taylor ahead by 3+ points needs to have their head examined. The judge that had Taylor up 5 oints should be banned from boxing.

[Decker]

Originally Posted by swedeone

1. Pavlik 10-9
2. Taylor 10-8
3. Pavlik 10-9
4. EVEN 10-10
5. Taylor 10-9
6. Pavlik 10-9

57-57 DEAD EVEN going into the 7th on my card. I have watched the fight 3 times now and could easily see it being 57-56 someone going into the 7th. Anyone that had Taylor ahead by 3+ points needs to have their head examined.

Good scoring, as was brooklyn1550's.

The judge that had Taylor up 5 points should be banned from boxing.

For life

[C Money]

If you think Taylor was ahead by 4, 5,or 6 points, its a fair question to ask "WTF were you watching?"

6-0??

[MrTod]

Originally Posted by raiderjay

Of course Bert Sugar had an awful scorecard. The man is a charicature of himself. He is an embarrasment to the sport of boxing. The general public unfortunately recognizes this biased piece of garbage as being "the voice of boxing". He then passes on revised history, pathetic uninformed opinions as fact. He is the king of misinformation to the general public when it comes to boxing. Just the sight of the man with his lame ass fedora and cheap cigars makes me want to puke.

Bert is completely irrelevant these days. he seems like the alzheimers-ridden uncle that people tolerate because he used to be well-respected. i actually spasm in discomfort when he dissects a fight.

[Ambition_Def]

Originally Posted by brooklyn1550

Exactly - the guy knows rumors but doesn't know much about actual boxing.

He's a contact guy. By no means a good analyst. If he were they'd have planted his ass on ESPN anyways. As if that would ever happen. I think Atlas would shit himself.

[fightingmajor]

Taylor was clearly winning, but definitely not every round. I had Taylor up 3 points and most other unbiased people did as well.