03' RingMag Top 100 Punchers

[Drew101]

Originally Posted by Jorodz

agreed. cooney's only real KO was a shot to shit Norton who was already devasted in his prime by Foreman and Shavers. other than that he bludgeoned Jimmy Young but failed to truly knock him out. despite some reports i feel he barely even stunned holmes as well and was completely outclassed by a FAR smaller spinks

Well, he did make Foreman wobble pretty badly in the first round with a nice counter left hook, and he also stopped an admittedly badly faded Lyle in a round as well. Plus for aesthetic value, the kayo of Norton iis pretty terrifying. But...I'm with you. 53 is probably too high of a rating for him.

[Jorodz]

Originally Posted by Drew101

Well, he did make Foreman wobble pretty badly in the first round with a nice counter left hook, and he also stopped an admittedly badly faded Lyle in a round as well. Plus for aesthetic value, the kayo of Norton iis pretty terrifying. But...I'm with you. 53 is probably too high of a rating for him.

oh for sure, he had power. and i forgot about the foreman and lyle fights but like you said he's too high. most of his reputation is built on the norton fight and while fun/horrifying to look at, isn't all that much in context. a ton of potential but couldn't prove it or use it against top tier opponents or consistently against b level opponents

[ricardoparker93]

David Tua is 30 odd places below Tyson? The list is pretty poor, I wonder if they believe that there are 24 harder punchers than Julian Jackson p4p

[Jorodz]

Originally Posted by ricardoparker93

David Tua is 30 odd places below Tyson? The list is pretty poor, I wonder if they believe that there are 24 harder punchers than Julian Jackson p4p

jackson is especially baffling. saad muhammad? very good, even great puncher but no jackson. same with graziano. zarate to i feel is a slightly better puncher than arguello or gomez but that's splitting hairs

also, the argument could be made for fitz to be even higher. while i look at it though, it's a pretty solid list considering how subjective the matter is.