Your P4P top 10?

[ishy]

Do you have a list? I don't but I'd like to see what other people think. The Ring's is very shit nowadays.

Yahoo Sports do a poll of boxing writers to compile their list [Only registered and activated users can see links. ]

I think that's quite decent. But should Shane Mosley be there and be ranked so highly? He's being inactive for more than a year. I think there should be a 12 month cut off period. If you don't fight for more than a year then you should be automatically dropped.

Also, IMO, the biggest criteria should be recent form and for me, in boxing, that means your opposition over the past two or so years. Bernard Hopkins, somehow, still gets credit for what he did 4,5 even 6 years ago. That's a load of bollocks. It should be a current list.

Anyway, your lists please

[LP_1985]

agree about hopkins pal but whether shane shud be there depends how he performs sat nite.

[Beeston Brawler]

1. Pacquiao/Mayweather
3. Marquez
4. Williams
5. WALDO
6. Hasegawa
7. Martinez
8. Adamek
9. Gamboa
10. Alexander

Mosley inactive..... Hopkins is done.... if Dawson beats Pascal he gets in there somewhere.

[antcull]

Pac
PBF
Mosely
Williams
JMM
Martinez
Dawson
Hasegawa
Wlad
Donaire

I find 1-7 very easy....but the last 3 spots hurt my head too much, those would change daily

[johna_83]

I dont really keep one but off the top my head my list would look something like;

1. Pacquiao
2. Mayweather
3. Mosley
4. Marquez
5. Dawson
6. P.Williams
7. Donaire
8. Caballero
9. Andre Ward
10. Martinez

With honourable mentions to Hasegawa, Bradley, Alexander, Gamboa and Juanma

[TFFP]

Pacquiao
Mayweather

[kosaros]

1. Manny Pacquiao
2. Floyd Mayweather
3. Juan Manuel Marquez
4. Paul Williams
5. Shane Mosley
6. Chad Dawson
7. Wladimir Klitschko
8. Hozumi Hasegawa
9. Sergio Martinez
10. Juan Manuel Lopez

[LP_1985]

Originally Posted by TFFP

Pacquiao
Mayweather

anything u want to add

[TFFP]

Originally Posted by LP_1985

anything u want to add

Flip a coin for the rest....

[ishy]

I like how Martinez is getting ranked after the Pavlik win yet Pavlik was one of the worst linear MW champs for yonks

Sergio is top 10 material for me as well though

[TFFP]

I suppose they could argue that Paul Williams didn't *really* conclusively beat Martinez and he's widely considered in the rankings. He was also ridiculously jobbed against Cintron and that should be considered a win.

[Losfer_Words]

Off of the top of my head:

1- Pacquiao
2- PBF
3- JMM
4- Cotto
5- Martinez
6- Williams
7- Dawson
8- Darchinyan
9- Wlad
10- Haye (WTF not?)

[TAM83]

Originally Posted by Losfer_Words

Off of the top of my head:

1- Pacquiao
2- PBF
3- JMM
4- Cotto
5- Martinez
6- Williams
7- Dawson
8- Darchinyan
9- Wlad
10- Haye (WTF not?)

I'd have him in before Bradley anyway

[icemax]

Originally Posted by Beeston Brawler

1. Pacquiao/Mayweather
3. Marquez
4. Williams
5. WALDO
6. Hasegawa
7. Martinez
8. Adamek
9. Gamboa
10. Alexander

Mosley inactive..... Hopkins is done.... if Dawson beats Pascal he gets in there somewhere.

Adamek??

[TAM83]

Originally Posted by icemax

Adamek??

Good question