Official Aussie NRL Thread - Page 590

pecks · 07-23-2012, 04:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stiflers mum

He left the ground. His was worse than Prior's but he will get off.

Disagree.
Prior elbowed a guy in the head. GI's initial contact was in the chest. GI never left the ground, and had Young not of turned forward at the last second, it would have been nearly impossible for GI to hit him in the head. Not saying that Young isnt allowed to look forward

but I really struggle to understand why the tackle was graded a grade 4. Union players who shoulder charge and get suspended for it get less than that, and the shoulder charge is illegal in union.

GI's was hardly different to Pritchard's and Teo's earlier in the season. They get 1 week, GI gets 4.

It's a poor decision, and the NRL is still too heavily influenced by fancyboy pen men like Rothfield, etc.

Rooster4Life · 07-23-2012, 04:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rusty nails

contact is made with the head nearly every tackle. luke bailey got forearmed in the face twice in one set on the weekend and noone has said boo about it. but because this was a good shot its ok to punish it?

its pretty simple really, when you see a guy put his full force into a shoulder charge that makes contact with the head, which causes the guy to be KOed for 5mins, that is 3-4 weeks.

Shoulder charges are great but hitting the head is far too dangerous. you could die from it if your hit just right.

Rooster4Life · 07-23-2012, 04:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pecks

Disagree.
Prior elbowed a guy in the head. GI's initial contact was in the chest. GI never left the ground, and had Young not of turned forward at the last second, it would have been nearly impossible for GI to hit him in the head. Not saying that Young isnt allowed to look forward

but I really struggle to understand why the tackle was graded a grade 4. Union players who shoulder charge and get suspended for it get less than that, and the shoulder charge is illegal in union.

GI's was hardly different to Pritchard's and Teo's earlier in the season. They get 1 week, GI gets 4.

It's a poor decision, and the NRL is still too heavily influenced by fancyboy pen men like Rothfield, etc.

i agree with that tho

rusty nails · 07-23-2012, 04:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooster4Life

its pretty simple really, when you see a guy put his full force into a shoulder charge that makes contact with the head, which causes the guy to be KOed for 5mins, that is 3-4 weeks.

Shoulder charges are great but hitting the head is far too dangerous. you could die from it if your hit just right.

if dean young got up and played on nobody would give two flying fucks about that tackle.

fact

abe01 · 07-23-2012, 04:55 AM

I think inglis will cop the 5weeks so the nrl can show they are serious about player safety/concusion.do you think if it was mick Crocker the ref would off sent him?

pecks · 07-23-2012, 04:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooster4Life

its black and white that you cant make contact with the head, Inglis will get what he deserves, JWH got 1 week last week for far far less.

Says the guy with the pink flaming homo avatar. 1 week is also far far less than 4

. Shoulder charge contact to the head isnt allowed, but initial contact wasnt made in the head. Why does he deserve 4 weeks when Teo and Pritchard only got 1?
Did Pritchard and Manu not make contact with their opponents head also?

How about Manu's which isnt too different to GI's then. Do you know how many he got? 0

When you're done explaining why, get down on your knees and start sucking, boy.

pecks · 07-23-2012, 05:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rusty nails

if dean young got up and played on nobody would give two flying fucks about that tackle.

fact

The hilarity of it all is, is that if his team matyes were so concerned about his wellbeing, why did they do their best to incite an all in brawl diurectly over the top of his unconscious laying body.

wide_open_road · 07-23-2012, 05:02 AM

Pritchards tackle was far worse, he actually lifted his arm up & his shoulder, Inglis didnt

stiflers mum · 07-23-2012, 05:14 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pecks

Disagree.
Prior elbowed a guy in the head. GI's initial contact was in the chest. GI never left the ground, and had Young not of turned forward at the last second, it would have been nearly impossible for GI to hit him in the head. Not saying that Young isnt allowed to look forward

but I really struggle to understand why the tackle was graded a grade 4. Union players who shoulder charge and get suspended for it get less than that, and the shoulder charge is illegal in union.

GI's was hardly different to Pritchard's and Teo's earlier in the season. They get 1 week, GI gets 4.

It's a poor decision, and the NRL is still too heavily influenced by fancyboy pen men like Rothfield, etc.

It looked bad. I don't think the NRL is influenced by the media. Anyway he will get off just like he did when he he gave his missus a shiner.

pecks · 07-23-2012, 05:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by stiflers mum

It looked bad. I don't think the NRL is influenced by the media. Anyway he will get off just like he did when he he gave his missus a shiner.

he wont get off, but by the rules of the game, it should never be a grade 4. Grade 1 or 2 at worst, but grade 4?

Travis Burns' was a bit harsh too. I guess Ian Roberts had his gaping arsecunt rags today.

rusty nails · 07-23-2012, 06:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by wide_open_road

Pritchards tackle was far worse, he actually lifted his arm up & his shoulder, Inglis didnt

exactly. cocked elbow if ever there was one

donkeyking · 07-23-2012, 06:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooster4Life

i agree with that tho

Whats with your avatar? Did you change teams?

BoppaZoo · 07-23-2012, 06:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rusty nails

the inglis hit should be on every nrl highlights segment for the next decade.

I agree

pecks · 07-23-2012, 06:45 AM

Tigers are dropping like flies. Moltzen, Masoe, and about 2 others injured.

Benji is trying to be too titty and is putting his team under uneccessary pressure. The short drop out in the 50th minute when you're only down by a try was just awful, and he's been doing too much of that shit for a while now.

aussie opinion · 07-23-2012, 11:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by pecks

Tigers are dropping like flies. Moltzen, Masoe, and about 2 others injured.

Benji is trying to be too titty and is putting his team under uneccessary pressure. The short drop out in the 50th minute when you're only down by a try was just awful, and he's been doing too much of that shit for a while now.

im happy keeps the mighty knights alive ..along with about 4 others

07-23-2012, 04:55 AM	#8840
abe01 Contender ESB Senior Member Join Date: Jan 2010 Posts: 793 vCash: 415	Re: Official Aussie NRL Thread I think inglis will cop the 5weeks so the nrl can show they are serious about player safety/concusion.do you think if it was mick Crocker the ref would off sent him?
Top

07-23-2012, 05:02 AM	#8843
wide_open_road Undisputed Champion East Side VIP Join Date: Mar 2010 Posts: 11,486 vCash: 187	Re: Official Aussie NRL Thread Pritchards tackle was far worse, he actually lifted his arm up & his shoulder, Inglis didnt
Top

07-23-2012, 06:45 AM	#8849
pecks *** East Side VIP** Join Date: Feb 2005 Location: Sydney, Australia Posts: 12,306 vCash: 1908	Re: Official Aussie NRL Thread Tigers are dropping like flies. Moltzen, Masoe, and about 2 others injured. Benji is trying to be too titty and is putting his team under uneccessary pressure. The short drop out in the 50th minute when you're only down by a try was just awful, and he's been doing too much of that shit for a while now.
Top