Rank the p4p top 5 in MMA

[Will Munny]

1. GSP
2. Jones
3. Cigano
4. Aldo
5. Cruz
6. Edgar
7. Melendez
8. Anderson

[kokoko]

Aldo
Edgar
JDS
Cruz
Henderson Dan

[Ubersteve]

1. Edgar
2. Cruz
3. Aldo
4. JDS
5. Benavidez

[Mike W]

Rashad Evans is the best fighter in MMA

[Flash Jab]

Originally Posted by Mike W

Rashad Evans is the best fighter in MMA

Mike W slurps his uncle cum at breakfast whilst he dances naked on the table and watches Rashad Evans' greatest hits.

[Mike W]

Flash Jab takes off his clothes and wants to join Brent and Luda in their gay strip club. They all take off their clothes for other men and dance naked together

[Stoo]

Mike W's Uncle is the top wanking MMA fighter in the world

[Beouche]

Originally Posted by Mike W

Rashad Evans is the best fighter in MMA

nice to see ya Mike

[Popkins]

Originally Posted by Beouche

Outside of Anderson GSP and Bones

Dominick Cruz
Junior dos Santos
Frankie Edgar
Dan Henderson
Gilbert Melendez

[Matty lll]

Originally Posted by Popkins

Dominick Cruz
Junior dos Santos
Frankie Edgar
Dan Henderson
Gilbert Melendez

Cruz #1? No Aldo?!

[Popkins]

Originally Posted by Matty lll

Cruz #1? No Aldo or Jones?!

Read the thread

[Matty lll]

Originally Posted by Popkins

Read the thread

I keep forgetting no Jones, but still no Aldo? Seriously?

[No Fear]

What is the definition of 'Pound for Pound' in this thread then? Just so we're all clear what the TS is seeking.

[Popkins]

Originally Posted by Matty lll

I keep forgetting no Jones, but still no Aldo? Seriously?

Very seriously. Aldo has not impressed me in his fights with Florian and Hominick. He would be my #6 (probably), but I don't think he is well-rounded enough or in good enough form to be a top p4p guy at the moment.

[BewareofDawg]

Originally Posted by Popkins

Very seriously. Aldo has not impressed me in his fights with Florian and Hominick. He would be my #6 (probably), but I don't think he is well-rounded enough or in good enough form to be a top p4p guy at the moment.

Dude he has dominated Faber, beat up Hominick (although appeared to gas in the last round), and clearly beat Florian (although in a boring fight where he didn't do much).

You have Edgar above him, who arguably lost the first fight to Penn, and the rematch to Maynard. Even if you score those for Edgar as the judges did, his performances weren't better than Aldo's vs Florian and Hominick.

Also Henderson isn't even the best in his weightclass, or the weightclass he came from where he lost clearly to Shields and got beat up by Anderson. I think the fight with Shogun could've been a draw, a fight in which he barely survived the last round spending most of the time mounted.