After last night's brutal TKO: my top 10 P4P

[seansanashee]

Originally Posted by Boxalot

1. Mayweather
2. Juan Manuel Marquez
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Andre Ward
5. Nonito Donaire
6. Sergio Martinez
7. Carl Froch
8. Wladimir Klitschko
9. Chad Dawson
10. Abner Mares

Thought about Moreno, Cotto, Bradley, Gamboa, Vitali etc and it is close towards the lower half.

People won't be happy with Pacquiao below Marquez but fuck it, he lost the fight. If he beats Bradley without any controversy then he goes back to #2.

Why is Kessler not being taken into consideration? He brutally KO'd Allan Green a few weeks ago at light heavy and only ever lost to Ward and Calzaghe.

[Boxalot]

Originally Posted by megavolt

Froch, Mares, Moreno, Vitali all borderline for me.

Yeah, it's close towards the bottom but Froch definitely deserves his place imo. Wins over undefeated versions of Bute, Pascal and Dirrell aswell as away wins over Taylor and AA (who's only defeat had been a DQ loss and he put his last two opponents into retirement permanently damaged) makes him a shoe-in for me.

[Boxalot]

Originally Posted by seansanashee

Why is Kessler not being taken into consideration? He brutally KO'd Allan Green a few weeks ago at light heavy and only ever lost to Ward and Calzaghe.

His last two opponents have been Allan Green and Mehdi Bouadla, which isn't quite good enough for me. I fucking love Kessler but those two are his only victories in the last two years.

[megavolt]

Originally Posted by Boxalot

Yeah, it's close towards the bottom but Froch definitely deserves his place imo. Wins over undefeated versions of Bute, Pascal and Dirrell aswell as away wins over Taylor and AA (who's only defeat had been a DQ loss and he put his last two opponents into retirement permanently damaged) makes him a shoe-in for me.

hmm compelling argument, looks like I can reconsider after seeing his top 5 splayed out like that

[NeroN]

Originally Posted by rodney

No.
Easy fight for Froche.
Bute was shittin his pants.
Gave way too much respect.
Had the DOG brought out in him.

GTFO you little hater. Nonito Donaire is motsly in the P4P because of his wins over Darch and Montiel, both were "easy" fights by your retarded standards.

[Bladegunner]

Originally Posted by Young Terror

Stopped reading at 1.

Because you never learned anything after that

[canucks9314]

Money
Manny
JMM
Ward
Sergio
Donaire
Wlad
Bradley
Cotto
Dawson

[gr33nfather]

-Pascal
-Bute
-Stevenson
-Alcine
-Lemieux
-?
-?
-?
-?
-?

[RANGEFINDER JAB]

Originally Posted by megavolt

After Froch's brutal knock-out of Bute, here's my top 10 p4p.



1. Mayweather
2. Pacquiao
3. Marquez
4. Donaire
5. Martinez
6. Ward
7. W. Klitschko
8. Bradley
9. Gamboa
10. Dawson

Where's Adamek?

[MrOliverKlozoff]

Originally Posted by seansanashee

Why is Kessler not being taken into consideration? He brutally KO'd Allan Green a few weeks ago at light heavy and only ever lost to Ward and Calzaghe.

Because Miranda outboxed Green and senior citizen Glen Johnson knocked him out before that. I love Kessler but knocking out Allan Green at any weight does not put him on a p4p list.

[rodney]

Originally Posted by NeroN

GTFO you little hater. Nonito Donaire is motsly in the P4P because of his wins over Darch and Montiel, both were "easy" fights by your retarded standards.

I actually liked the guy. Big disappoinent. I have to tell it like I see it. Bute was shittin. Scared to punch. Everybody saw for he bring the DOG out in Bute.

[Zombieguy]

Swap Martinez and Marquez and that's a damn fine list.

[irwin]

Originally Posted by Young Terror

Stopped reading at 1.