Post your Top 10 ATG Heavyweight list.

[Hattons Hook]

Originally Posted by McGrain

[Only registered and activated users can see links. ]

Made my day

[manbearpig]

tradger

[frankenfrank]

i quit , u kip postin shit ai dont anderstend , end not xpleining wen ai ask ebaut it

[manbearpig]

Yassss ya dancer

[Asterion]

Originally Posted by SuzieQ49

1. Joe Louis
2. Muhammad Ali
3. Larry Holmes
4. Lennox Lewis
5. Rocky Marciano
6. Sonny Liston
7. George Foreman
8. Mike Tyson
9. Joe Frazier
10. Wladimir Klitschko

This list is very similar to mine, although I rank Lewis a bit lower and Foreman a bit higher.

[Seamus]

1) John L Sullivan
2) James Corbett
3) Peter Jackson
4) Joe Goddard
5) Peter Maher
6) Charley Mitchell
7) Paddy Ryan
Jim Hall
9) Paddy Slavin
10) Wladmir Klitschko

[PhillyPhan69]

Originally Posted by Seamus

1) John L Sullivan
2) James Corbett
3) Peter Jackson
4) Joe Goddard
5) Peter Maher
6) Charley Mitchell
7) Paddy Ryan
Jim Hall
9) Paddy Slavin
10) Wladmir Klitschko

Liar!

[Hattons Hook]

1. Durk Haye
2. Dave Balamory
3. Jesper Krankjear
4. Crap Phelan
5. Kent Clarke
6. Jeremy " Bonecrusher " Simpkins
7. Alec Guiness
8. Scott Bond
9. Hank " The Bite " Axe
10. Little " Andrew " Plum

[orriray59]

1: Muhammad Ali
2: Joe Louis
3: Larry Holmes
4: Lennox Lewis
5: Joe Frazier
6: George Foreman
7: Rocky Marciano
8: Mike Tyson
9: Evander Holyfield
10: Jack Dempsey

[Vic-JofreBRASIL]

1-Louis
2-Ali
3-Lewis
4-Holmes
5-Foreman
6-Frazier
7-Marciano
8-Holyfield
9-Tyson
10-Dempsey


11- Wlad

[ripcity]

1. Joe Louis: The best boxer the heavyweight division has seen. There are a few guys he could have fought. Such as Lem Franklin and Elmer Ray. A great combo of fundmentals and power. You don't win 26 championships with out losing with out a lot of talent.
2. Muhammad Ali: Tall, quick and awkard a young Ali would be trubble for anyone. I think the heavyweight division was comming into its own when he was forced in to exile. In his return he was sly and tough. He also beat some of the best chalangers ever. He also lost to them.
3. Rockey Marciano: You don't go 49-0 without being really good.
4. Lenox Lewis: Lewis and Mariciano are the only heavyweight champions as far as I know to beat everyone they faced. While I think Bowe would have beaten him had they fought. Lewis is the most secusfuell gaint heavyweight.
5. Mike Tyson: There are two non gaint heavyweights who can beat the gaints. One is Louis the other is Tyson. One of the best combontions of agression and defense.
6. Larry Holmes: Technaly as good if not better than anyone. Despite this and a great record. He lacks a defining win.
7. Riddick Bowe: From 92-95, maybe 96 (I belive Golatas punching him in the balls had a major effect on their fights). Bowe Is my pick to win a head to head touny. He could fight on the outside like a giant should and on the inside when needed. He also had a really good chin. Something that a lot of giants lack.
8. Wald Klitchko: If he keeps winning, he can climb up a few spots. He might not be exciting, but his style is effectve.
9. George Foreman: If this was about talent alone. Foreman Would not be on my list. The fact is that as ugly as his fighting style was. He won fights.
10. Joe Fraizer: Had the best win in heavyweight history when he beat Ali in 1971. Almost did it again in their third fight. Probbly more of an over acheiver than a great talent. Beat some good contenders, but other than his win over Ali came uup short against the top heavyweights of his day.

[orriray59]

Originally Posted by Vic-JofreBRASIL

1-Louis
2-Ali
3-Lewis
4-Holmes
5-Foreman
6-Frazier
7-Marciano
8-Holyfield
9-Tyson
10-Dempsey


11- Wlad

My list and yours are spookily close.

[Webbiano]

Originally Posted by ripcity

1. Joe Louis: The best boxer the heavyweight division has seen. There are a few guys he could have fought. Such as Lem Franklin and Elmer Ray. A great combo of fundmentals and power. You don't win 26 championships with out losing with out a lot of talent.
2. Muhammad Ali: Tall, quick and awkard a young Ali would be trubble for anyone. I think the heavyweight division was comming into its own when he was forced in to exile. In his return he was sly and tough. He also beat some of the best chalangers ever. He also lost to them.
3. Rockey Marciano: You don't go 49-0 without being really good.
4. Lenox Lewis: Lewis and Mariciano are the only heavyweight champions as far as I know to beat everyone they faced. While I think Bowe would have beaten him had they fought. Lewis is the most secusfuell gaint heavyweight.
5. Mike Tyson: There are two non gaint heavyweights who can beat the gaints. One is Louis the other is Tyson. One of the best combontions of agression and defense.
6. Larry Holmes: Technaly as good if not better than anyone. Despite this and a great record. He lacks a defining win.
7. Riddick Bowe: From 92-95, maybe 96 (I belive Golatas punching him in the balls had a major effect on their fights). Bowe Is my pick to win a head to head touny. He could fight on the outside like a giant should and on the inside when needed. He also had a really good chin. Something that a lot of giants lack.
8. Wald Klitchko: If he keeps winning, he can climb up a few spots. He might not be exciting, but his style is effectve.
9. George Foreman: If this was about talent alone. Foreman Would not be on my list. The fact is that as ugly as his fighting style was. He won fights.
10. Joe Fraizer: Had the best win in heavyweight history when he beat Ali in 1971. Almost did it again in their third fight. Probbly more of an over acheiver than a great talent. Beat some good contenders, but other than his win over Ali came uup short against the top heavyweights of his day.

I'm guessing your list places a lot of emphasis on H2H because Bowe hardly deserves a top 15 spot in my eyes

[choklab]

1.joe louis
2 muhammad ali
3 rocky marciano
4 dempsey
5 holmes
6 johnson
7 lennox lewis
8 holyfeild - resilient, longevity but only 2nd best of his era
9 Frazier - almost matched Marciano had he retired in 72’
10 Tyson best of his era

[choklab]

Originally Posted by PhillyPhan69

01 Louis
02 Ali

03 Holmes
04 Foreman

05 Frazier
06 Johnson
07 Marciano

08 Holyfield
09 Tyson
10 Lewis

11 Jeffries
12 Dempsey
13 Liston
14 Wlad

15 Schmeling
16 Bowe
17 Vitali

18 Patterson
19 Charles
20 Walcott

GOOD LIST. i would swap marciano amd foreman around though. Foreman never had his own era.