Best All time great vs. All time great performance..

[PhillyPhan69]

Originally Posted by KuRuPT

which fight and win was the most impressive to you:

1. Frazier vs. Ali 1
2. Whitaker vs. Chavez
3. Duran vs. SRL
4. SRL vs. Hagler
5. Charles vs. Walcott 3

I am partial to Armstrong vs Ross.....

out of those listed:
Duran-SRL

Frazier-Ali
Charles-Walcott



SRL-Hagler (Good performance, but past prime for both and a draw on my card)
Chavez vs Whitaker- I disagree with the announcers and the world...JCC was past prime weight and I still scored it a draw...don't believe the hype!

[Hands of Iron]

[NoNeck]

Roy Jones' win over James Toney

[Rex Tickard]

Originally Posted by Hands of Iron

Sugar was right on the money, on all counts.

[Rex Tickard]

Originally Posted by KuRuPT

which fight and win was the most impressive to you:

1. Frazier vs. Ali 1
2. Whitaker vs. Chavez
3. Duran vs. SRL
4. SRL vs. Hagler
5. Charles vs. Walcott 3

I'm going to go against what appears to be the grain here, and pick Walcott-Charles. For starters, it was the most dominant performance of the bunch, and the only one to be ended by KO. I would also argue that Walcott's feat was the most seemingly improbable of the bunch - winning the HW title at age 37, against a much younger man who had already beaten him twice, and ending it with a single punch. I would also argue that Charles was the most accomplished of the losing fighters heading into his loss - remember, Ali and Leonard would go on score most of their biggest victories after losing. Also, Charles may be the only of the losing fighters that was still at his peak heading into the loss - Leonard was still a bit green, Ali was definitely a bit past it, Hagler and possibly Chavez were slightly past it was well.

[recycling]

Marquez ko pacquaio trumps everything listed

[lufcrazy]

Duran v Leonard.

[Tin_Ribs]

That haven't been mentioned yet, I think....

Harada vs Jofre
Fitz vs Nonpareil
McFarland vs Gibbons
Saldivar vs Ramos
Gomez vs Zarate
Kid Choc vs Canzi (or vice versa)
Greb vs Walker
Rose vs Harada
Olivares vs Rose
Driscoll vs Attell
Loi vs Ortiz III
Kalambay vs McCallum
Hatton vs Tackie

[lora]

Chavez was so overrated by the early-mid 90s.

It was like three quarters of the boxing media were stuck in a 1987 timewarp.

[LittleRed]

Originally Posted by lora

Chavez was so overrated by the early-mid 90s.

It was like three quarters of the boxing media were stuck in a 1987 timewarp.

Yeah he was clearly not the guy he had been even a few years before. Hell George Foreman picked Whitaker to whip Chavez cleanly.

[Cc..]

Hearns vs Leonard is one of the best boxing performances i've seen untill the last 2/3 rounds before the KO. Not saying it should be counted because at the end of the day it was a loss, but just thought it was worth a mention.

[sweet_scientist]

Originally Posted by LittleRed

Yeah he was clearly not the guy he had been even a few years before. Hell George Foreman picked Whitaker to whip Chavez cleanly.

Foreman is a genius. Inventor of the Foreman grill.

[Hands of Iron]

Originally Posted by LittleRed

Yeah he was clearly not the guy he had been even a few years before.

Whitaker still wins.

It's alright though, Julio is probably the second greatest fighter of the last quarter-century.

[Hands of Iron]

"I've been chasing this guy for two years," he said of Chavez. "I tried to meet him at lightweight and then at junior welterweight, and now I'm 147. We'll fight at 147. I'm not going to keep giving him alternatives just to keep him happy."


Yet, there was still an alternative. Chavez threatened to pull out when an American judge was appointed.

[LittleRed]

Originally Posted by sweet_scientist

Foreman is a genius. Inventor of the Foreman grill.

You know I actually think, having listened to a whole bunch of Foremans' commentary, that he was a knowledgeable guy. He just wasn't particularly articulate and was a contrarian by nature, which led to some of his more notable nonsense. You would have to be stubborn, to believe you could win the title back at that age.

Originally Posted by Hands of Iron

Whitaker still wins.

It's alright though, Julio is probably the second greatest fighter of the last quarter-century.

Yep. It would have been a much better fight though. I think their actual encounter was boring and foul filled.