Joe Calzaghe

[Momus]

Originally Posted by Mind Reader

Joe Calzaghe was an all time great fighter IMO.. I am sure many would criticize me for saying that, but when you combine his longevity, natural ability, effective aggression for a full 12 rounds, greatest at his primary weight class, and he does have some quality wins...... How could he not be ATG?

Out of interest, how are you defining 'ATG'?

[Mind Reader]

Originally Posted by Momus

Out of interest, how are you defining 'ATG'?

I am actually not too sure...

I can't even make my own top 10 list..

I pretty much just look at a fighter's career, wins, losses, ability, opponents fought ect, and decide if i think they were really good or "all time great"

Judging ATG is for sure not an exact science.. I start to argue with myself over the top 3 fighters, so I realize what people think is great is certainly subjective... But I have seen lists that I wouldn't strongly argue with, and I generally think ATG would be falling somewhere in the top 100...

I wouldn't argue with Joe being top 100