Please, Rank The Victory: Volume 2: Jack Dempsey KO7 Jack Sharkey

[Unforgiven]

Originally Posted by Colonel Sanders

yes thank you very much, nobody talks about how Sharkey took a very cheap shot to Dempsey's jaw well after the bell at the end of the round just before he got knocked out

too much Skarkey apologists for my liking, what comes around goes around

I also wonder how people can score the fight in one-sided fashion in favor of Sharkey, it's an inside fight for the most part and the poor quality of the footage makes it hard to see what is landing clean, head or body

there is no indication that Sharkey would have won that fight had there been no low blow-hook to the jaw combo

I think Sharkey had done well early on but the fight had changed distinctly by the time the end occurred. Dempsey had been coming on strong and finding his range inside for two rounds prior. He's weathered Sharkey's early success and the fight was heating up.
I don't want to glorify or embellsh Dempsey's performance, it was a flawed performance and a little tarnished but the main thing I think Sharkey was a spoiled front-runner in this fight.

[red cobra]

Originally Posted by Colonel Sanders

yes thank you very much, nobody talks about how Sharkey took a very cheap shot to Dempsey's jaw well after the bell at the end of the round just before he got knocked out

too much Skarkey apologists for my liking, what comes around goes around

I also wonder how people can score the fight in one-sided fashion in favor of Sharkey, it's an inside fight for the most part and the poor quality of the footage makes it hard to see what is landing clean, head or body

there is no indication that Sharkey would have won that fight had there been no low blow-hook to the jaw combo

Maybe the low blow in the next round was a retaliation for that cheap shot.

[janitor]

Not many long reigning lineal heavyweight champions beat the heir to their throne.

Joe Louis beat Joe Walcott.

Lennox Lewis beat Vitally Klitschko.

[edward morbius]

RED COBRA--"I wanted to edit out the word bastard, after all, I have some standards."

I used the word bastard to describe Sharkey in the Joe Louis thread. It was a common usage word when I was young and no one got that excited. I would probably have been pleased if my drill sergeant stuck to calling me a bastard.

Growing up on a farm, it was the term for a male dog, with bitch for a female dog.

I checked with the American Kennel Club Board and yes, that is or was correct.

It does refer to an illegitimate boy, but that was a secondary use in those days and I didn't find out about that until I was educated.

Now the word has become politically incorrect, so I changed it in the Joe Louis beat five champions thread to "creep" which does seem to lack the same snap.

Hope you guys weren't offended.

[guilalah]

I voted '8', by which I mean 'very good'. Some iffy punches in the last round keep it from being a '9' (excellent). Sharkey had won most of the rounds, but Dempsey's body shot deposits seemed to be drawing interest. I get the feeling the fight was starting to turn. Big win in Dempsey's career, shows that even in decline he was probably still the next best active hvywt after Tunney.

[SuzieQ49]

there is no indication that Sharkey would have won that fight had there been no low blow-hook to the jaw combo

You're kidding right? Dempsey won only 1 of the first 6 rounds on any normal scorecard.

[Colonel Sanders]

Originally Posted by SuzieQ49

You're kidding right? Dempsey won only 1 of the first 6 rounds on any normal scorecard.

as has been stated by some posters, the tide appeared to be turning

it was scheduled for 15 rounds, I think Dempsey would have broken down Sharkey down the stretch, as Sharkey was fighting Dempsey's fight

and as I said, how can you score the fight so one-sidedly for Sharkey, the footage quality is very poor

[Dempsey1238]

Originally Posted by janitor

Not many long reigning lineal heavyweight champions beat the heir to their throne.

Joe Louis beat Joe Walcott.

Lennox Lewis beat Vitally Klitschko.

Well Dempsey beat the heir of his heir lol.

[Dempsey1238]

Originally Posted by Colonel Sanders

as has been stated by some posters, the tide appeared to be turning

it was scheduled for 15 rounds, I think Dempsey would have broken down Sharkey down the stretch, as Sharkey was fighting Dempsey's fight

and as I said, how can you score the fight so one-sidedly for Sharkey, the footage quality is very poor

Footage is bad, but you can still sort of tell whats going on I guess. I think I score it 4-2 for Sharkey about. I think it got dirty the movement Sharkey hit Dempsey after the bell. Dempsey answer back. As for a points victory, a win is a win, no matter how it happen.

I give it a 6 though, but I not going to used this win to support or tear down Dempsey here. It got Dempsey to the rematch. Dempsey is ranked more on his wins over Firpo, or Willard and his 2 clashes with Tunney. The Sharkey fight is hardly ever brought up. Outside of the ending of couse.

[edward morbius]

Originally Posted by SuzieQ49

You're kidding right? Dempsey won only 1 of the first 6 rounds on any normal scorecard.

I tried to find out what the official scorecards said and couldn't, but I did find this post right here on ESB

Maxmomer 3-1-2009 8:57

"I just read an interesting article on this fight."

Later in his post, he posted this

"Also, out of the scorecards of the two judges and the referee 5 rounds were even, 6 for Dempsey, and 7 for Sharkey."

***I have no way of knowing if Max's article is correct, but if it is, the official scoring was very close and Dempsey could have pulled ahead if he took the 7th.

[edward morbius]

I just rewatched the entire film.

I had it 3-2-1 for Sharkey going into the 7th.

Sharkey certainly fought well, but he fought Dempsey inside the whole fight and was taking a body beating in my opinion. It wasn't like Dempsey was constantly eating jabs like he did again the retreating Tunney. This fight was close.

[MadcapMaxie]

Originally Posted by Colonel Sanders

as has been stated by some posters, the tide appeared to be turning

it was scheduled for 15 rounds, I think Dempsey would have broken down Sharkey down the stretch, as Sharkey was fighting Dempsey's fight

and as I said, how can you score the fight so one-sidedly for Sharkey, the footage quality is very poor

Just to play Devils Advocate but who did Dempsey ever break down over the stretch and which fight did he end up turning the tide after having been beaten for the 1st half of a fight? IIRC there are no such examples and Dempsey never KO'd someone beyond the 6th round (excluding this fight of course).

[edward morbius]

Originally Posted by MadcapMaxie

Just to play Devils Advocate but who did Dempsey ever break down over the stretch and which fight did he end up turning the tide after having been beaten for the 1st half of a fight? IIRC there are no such examples and Dempsey never KO'd someone beyond the 6th round (excluding this fight of course).

"who did Dempsey ever break down over the stretch and which fight did he end up turning the tide after having been beaten for the 1st half of the fight?"

Bill Brennan--1920

[mcvey]

Originally Posted by MadcapMaxie

Just to play Devils Advocate but who did Dempsey ever break down over the stretch and which fight did he end up turning the tide after having been beaten for the 1st half of a fight? IIRC there are no such examples and Dempsey never KO'd someone beyond the 6th round (excluding this fight of course).

Would that be because Dempsey kod the vast majority of his opposition early?
Off the top of my head I think he only went that distance around 12 times ,two of which he lost ,to Tunney, one a dec win with Gibbons , one a draw with Miske.
He did score three late kos when he was a novice,and ,as has been said he stopped Brennan late.
Should we penalise him for taking opponents out early?

Dempsey was getting back in the fight ,his corner instructions were "keep pounding them in to his body", Sharkey was starting to wilt a bit imo. He was in front but the gap was closing, because he was fighting Dempsey's fight.

[Unforgiven]

Originally Posted by MadcapMaxie

Just to play Devils Advocate but who did Dempsey ever break down over the stretch and which fight did he end up turning the tide after having been beaten for the 1st half of a fight? IIRC there are no such examples and Dempsey never KO'd someone beyond the 6th round (excluding this fight of course).

Originally Posted by edward morbius

"who did Dempsey ever break down over the stretch and which fight did he end up turning the tide after having been beaten for the 1st half of the fight?"

Bill Brennan--1920

You beat me to it !

The Bill Brennan fight completely fits the description MadcapMaxie is looking for.