ATG Acid Test: Mayweather, Jr vs. Chavez, Sr.

[ripcity]

Floyd Mayweather, Jr
Record: 43-0-0 (26) / Peak: 43-0-0 (26)

Diego Corrales
Jose Luis Castillo (x2)
Oscar De La Hoya
Ricky Hatton
Genaro Hernandez
Miguel Cotto
Shane Mosley

Julio Cesar Chavez, Sr
Record: 107-6-2 (86) / Peak: 87-0-0 (72)

Meldrick Taylor (x2)
Edwin Rosario
Jose Luis Ramirez
Hector Camacho
Rocky Lockridge
Roger Mayweather (x2)
Mario Martinez

Going over these lists there are no two wins of Mayweather's that can top Chavez's wins of Edwin Rosario and Meldrick Taylor. In terms of quility of oppestion. However Mayweather's over all quility of oppistion is better.

Mayweather would win a match up at 130, 135 and 140. Chavez really wasn't relvent at 147.

[NWS]

Yeah, I'm sure Nonito(e) Smoak will come break down their top 20 wins.. I just listed the most relevant (to me). There are plenty of others for both of them.

[LACMEXAME]

This is ridiculous ha. JCC without a doubt.

[Nonito Smoak]

Wait another 30 years to get it all sorted out...

Too much bias from those who lived through and watched both, or just one of the two.

Plus, one of them isn't retired yet while the other is.

It is certainly an example of quality vs. quantity to some degree.

[Hatesrats]

IMO Chavez beats the piss out of Floyd 130-140
@147 & above Julio was not effective.

Bootleg Chavez gave "Prime" Floyd all he can handle twice.

[JM22]

Originally Posted by MVC

Floyd. You don't know shit about boxing, son.

Hell no! Castillo who is a poor poor poor version of JCC gave Mayweather hell and many (including myself) thought JLC beat him in their first fight, Just imagine what he would do to Mayweather.

[NWS]

Originally Posted by Hatesrats

^ Which ones??

I think he's saying Chavez has the best two wins (MT & Rosario) between them, 'Rats. I said the same thing on first page, but people don't really know Chapo or how he was supposed to take JCC's head off going into that fight.

[Hatesrats]

Originally Posted by NWS

I think he's saying Chavez has the best two wins (MT & Rosario) between them, 'Rats. I said the same thing on first page, but people don't really know Chapo or how he was supposed to take JCC's head off going into that fight.

Yeah... That's why I changed my post.
(Defensive)

[NWS]

Originally Posted by Hatesrats

Yeah... That's why I changed my post.
(Defensive)

Didn't see the edit.

[the cobra]

Originally Posted by Hatesrats

Bootleg Chavez gave "Prime" Floyd all he can handle twice.

[Hatesrats]

Originally Posted by MVC

How is Meldrick Taylor more dangerous and formidable than an undefeated Corrales, ODLH, Genaro, Cotto (154), among MANY others

Taylor at the time when he fought JCC had 1 decent victory, and that was vs Buddy.

McGirt arguably beats a "prime" Cotto @147. <~ McGirt very underrated as a fighter.
(The version May fought would get smoked against even bum shoulder McGirt)

Come on kid.

[NWS]

Like I said before...
(Your favorite saying)

How Isn't He?

[The Wanderer]

Chavez. Going over their records, there is no real comparison.

[NWS]

Originally Posted by LACMEXAME

This is ridiculous ha. JCC without a doubt.

I had doubts. Sort of surprised by poll, actually.

[Zopilote]

Originally Posted by MVC

Whitaker/ODLH gave Chavez a shitting

Floyd beat Castillo. Deal with it.

43-0, 8 world championships, 5 divisions, 3 time lineal champion.

Hey I can do it too. Chavez hasn't beaten anyone better than Corrales.

Of course you can, and you'd sound like a complete retard as well.