And still IBF world champion - Geale defeats Mundine via UD

[IrnBruMan]

Originally Posted by JOSEY WALES

Scratching my head as to which round he won myself Duke , I thought round four was the closest Mundine came to winning a round but even during that round I remember feeling Geale shaded it , No my original 120-108 score card is correct IMO , how Choc could even entertain the thought he got robbed is way beyond me , congratulations Danny Geale and don't forget to puff that chest out in the morning son ( that will be two days in a row you have taken someone to SCHOOL)

Same as my view of the fight

[LeBeave]

Originally Posted by TheDuke

What ****ing rounds did Mundine win lol

There's a strong case for rds 1 and 7 plus maybe 10 or 11 if i can remember.

No more than 3rds but to say Geale won every rd would be generous towards Geale and like saying Mundine won 4 rds in total.

Personally i had it 118 - 110

[StiffJab]

Originally Posted by LeBeave

There's a strong case for rds 1 and 7 plus maybe 10 or 11 if i can remember.

No more than 3rds but to say Geale won every rd would be generous towards Geale and like saying Mundine won 4 rds in total.

Personally i had it 118 - 110

There is no way in hell round 1 was anything less than a Geale round.

I think 7 was the only round you could consider and that alone was a long shot.

[TheDuke]

Originally Posted by LeBeave

There's a strong case for rds 1 and 7 plus maybe 10 or 11 if i can remember.

No more than 3rds but to say Geale won every rd would be generous towards Geale and like saying Mundine won 4 rds in total.

Personally i had it 118 - 110

Originally Posted by StiffJab

There is no way in hell round 1 was anything less than a Geale round.

I think 7 was the only round you could consider and that alone was a long shot.

Have to agree with the stiff one

[LeBeave]

I said there's a strong case for rds 1 and 7.... i didn't say it was a done deal. Personally i gave them to Mundine but can see maybe a 10-10 for the 1st rd as well.

Anyone that scored the fight 120-108 is being a little harsh and no doubt a non Mundine fan.

2 judges had Mundine winning 3rds and 1 judge 4rds. Again i only gave him 2rds

[StiffJab]

Originally Posted by LeBeave

I said there's a strong case for rds 1 and 7.... i didn't say it was a done deal. Personally i gave them to Mundine but can see maybe a 10-10 for the 1st rd as well.

Anyone that scored the fight 120-108 is being a little harsh and no doubt a non Mundine fan.

2 judges had Mundine winning 3rds and 1 judge 4rds. Again i only gave him 2rds

A strong case is not far off a done deal

IB has it a shut out and his a solid non bias judge of fights. Nearly everyone on the RBR thread had it a shut out or close to. Kegsy also scored a shut out and that man's as honest as it gets

I gave choc 1 round and I think the second round even as i was trying to be as unbias as possible, that alone was hard in itself as a self professed nuthugger

But each to their own

[Steel Kelly]

This was a clear cut win for Geale and if anything the judges were more than generous to Mundine. Mundine is a nutjob.

[Kegsy]

Originally Posted by StiffJab

There is no way in hell round 1 was anything less than a Geale round.

I think 7 was the only round you could consider and that alone was a long shot.

Well said.

[lvthefightgame]

I did not see the fight but saw 12 min of highlight & of what i saw geale threw lots but did not land many i thought pro boxing was about effective agression the mundine jab was stuck in geales face all night. mundines face barely had a mark on it. i was tuned into the round by round commentary last night on here & i have to say who ever was saying mundine was getting schooled should not have anything to do with boxing. some idiot said it was a shut out god i seen 12 min & it was clear it was a very close fight. in saying that good on geale for getting the nod & i hope he heads overseas & gets a really good opponent govolkin would be a good fight or martinez if i were daniel i would go after the green belt martinez big payday there. so i hope i dont offend to many people on here when i say most of you cant score a fight to save your self & maybe a bit racist i think thats what effected your judging & as for mundine walking out of the ring straight away did'nt geale do that in there first fight. cheers guys

[TheDuke]

Originally Posted by lvthefightgame

I did not see the fight but saw 12 min of highlight & of what i saw geale threw lots but did not land many i thought pro boxing was about effective agression the mundine jab was stuck in geales face all night. mundines face barely had a mark on it. i was tuned into the round by round commentary last night on here & i have to say who ever was saying mundine was getting schooled should not have anything to do with boxing. some idiot said it was a shut out god i seen 12 min & it was clear it was a very close fight. in saying that good on geale for getting the nod & i hope he heads overseas & gets a really good opponent govolkin would be a good fight or martinez if i were daniel i would go after the green belt martinez big payday there. so i hope i dont offend to many people on here when i say most of you cant score a fight to save your self & maybe a bit racist i think thats what effected your judging & as for mundine walking out of the ring straight away did'nt geale do that in there first fight. cheers guys

You watched 12 minutes of higlights and you think it was a close fight?

Racist? What the **** are you on about. He was beaten clear as day.

. Go to the round by round in the general where most international pundits scored it a shutout. Mundine threw very little and his head was snapping back every round due to Geale's punches LANDING - he was dominated and that's that.

[Giantcan]

Was it racist cos the whiter Aboriginal won?

[IrnBruMan]

Originally Posted by lvthefightgame

I did not see the fight...

So what the **** are you doing talking about it dumbarse?

[StiffJab]

I did not see the fight but saw 12 min of highlight

Ok bro. 12 mins of a 36 minute fight and you know it all.

Carry on

[The Kirwan Kid]

120-112 to geale for mine. I couldn't give Anthony a round (there were a few 10-10s) which I guess could have gone the other way. 118-112 being generous.

[stiflers mum]

Originally Posted by pourya

120-108 was if you were totally in favour of geale...
mundine won 2-3 rounds in there.. but thats about it

The 1st maybe and the 8th or somewhere around there that's it. Even that is debatable IMO.