Can any of today's guys become the best 147 of all time?

[thewoo]

or at least # 2 behind SRR?

147 is as stacked as it's ever been. Suppose Cotto were to fight and beat DLH, Mosley, Floyd, Williams, Margarito, Cintron, Clotty and Collazo. I know this is a huge if but lets suppose it were to happen or interchange some names with Floyd or williams beating all those other guys.

I am not as knowledgable as some of you other guys in terms of history but I would think that would be an ATG 147 resume no?

[Caper]

Originally Posted by thewoo

or at least # 2 behind SRR?

147 is as stacked as it's ever been. Suppose Cotto were to fight and beat DLH, Mosley, Floyd, Williams, Margarito, Cintron, Clotty and Collazo. I know this is a huge if but lets suppose it were to happen or interchange some names with Floyd or williams beating all those other guys.

I am not as knowledgable as some of you other guys in terms of history but I would think that would be an ATG 147 resume no?

That's one hell of a task even for superman, so yes he would go right behind SRR as a 47lbs maybe even #1

Huge IF..


But it can happen

WAR COTTO

[thunder06]

i believe if any guy from 147 beat all the other competition, an argument could be made for them to be a top 5 ATG welterweight. right now i believe cotto, mosley, hatton and mayweather have the potential to be an ATG.

[DaveTheWave]

Not a chance. We've seen the best. It won't get better.

[Caper]

Originally Posted by thunder06

i believe if any guy from 147 beat all the other competition, an argument could be made for them to be a top 5 ATG welterweight. right now i believe cotto, mosley, hatton and mayweather have the potential to be an ATG.

I's liketadid what you said too buddy

[thunder06]

Originally Posted by Caper

I's liketadid what you said too buddy

sure

[Caper]

Originally Posted by DaveTheWave

Not a chance. We've seen the best. It won't get better.

Please do tell

SRR yes but after that it seems 147lbs has been so staked it has made it difficult to get all the top fighters in the ring to see who still stands once the dust is clear. I have yet to see a fighter beat each and every top WW in their respective eras. Have you?

[Lance_Uppercut]

Originally Posted by thewoo

or at least # 2 behind SRR?

147 is as stacked as it's ever been. Suppose Cotto were to fight and beat DLH, Mosley, Floyd, Williams, Margarito, Cintron, Clotty and Collazo. I know this is a huge if but lets suppose it were to happen or interchange some names with Floyd or williams beating all those other guys.

I am not as knowledgable as some of you other guys in terms of history but I would think that would be an ATG 147 resume no?

That would be hard to ignore.

[Caper]

Originally Posted by thunder06

sure

Just busting your thunder sacs a little I had to deal with thousands of crying screaming women running down 42nd today so my compassion levels are a bit dry.

[Caper]

Originally Posted by Lance_Uppercut

That would be hard to ignore.

[Slothrop]

Perhaps the best way to phrase it would be that Cotto could put himself in the conversation.

[1lehudson]

Originally Posted by thewoo

or at least # 2 behind SRR?

147 is as stacked as it's ever been. Suppose Cotto were to fight and beat DLH, Mosley, Floyd, Williams, Margarito, Cintron, Clotty and Collazo. I know this is a huge if but lets suppose it were to happen or interchange some names with Floyd or williams beating all those other guys.

I am not as knowledgable as some of you other guys in terms of history but I would think that would be an ATG 147 resume no?

Keep in mind that the guy that is number 2 on most lists beat hearns, Duran, Hagler, Benitez dispite missing alot of his prime with the eye injury. Keep in mind that most of that work was done before Ray was 26 years old.

You would even have a hard time making a strong case for number three depending on were you have Armstrong, who I think is p4p number 2 all times, but not as high at welterweight.

[Martini643]

Originally Posted by thewoo

or at least # 2 behind SRR?

147 is as stacked as it's ever been. Suppose Cotto were to fight and beat DLH, Mosley, Floyd, Williams, Margarito, Cintron, Clotty and Collazo. I know this is a huge if but lets suppose it were to happen or interchange some names with Floyd or williams beating all those other guys.

I am not as knowledgable as some of you other guys in terms of history but I would think that would be an ATG 147 resume no?

The only fighters that you mentioned i think who would have a chance as an ATG not the best of all time but a top 5 welterweight would be Cotto or Mayweather. Mosley is on his way out of the sport in another year or 2 and can't possibly beat all those you mentioned. Cintron,Collazo are good fighters but I don't see an ATG in either of them. Paul Williams I think is a good fighter but I think he will be picked apart by Mayweather or Cotto.

[1lehudson]

Originally Posted by Martini643

The only fighters that you mentioned i think who would have a chance as an ATG not the best of all time but a top 5 welterweight would be Cotto or Mayweather. Mosley is on his way out of the sport in another year or 2 and can't possibly beat all those you mentioned. Cintron,Collazo are good fighters but I don't see an ATG in either of them. Paul Williams I think is a good fighter but I think he will be picked apart by Mayweather or Cotto.

Oh I think that Shane right now has a better shot then both Floyd and Cotto. Keep in mind he already has some really big wins, and all it would take of him would be beatting Floyd and Cotton and maybe one other Cintron or Williams. that would put him about as high as any of these fighters can get.

And the reason that I think that the limit is capped is because some of there guys will be exposed as not great fighters. You have to beat all-timers to be all-timers. While i think that these guys are all very good fighters none of them are great fighters. Robinson and leonard beat all time greats top 20 fighters.

[CASH_718]

If one person clears out the whole division I'd put them #2 behind SRR for sure.