Fritzie Zivic...Welterweight Champion in 1940 & 1941. Beat Jake LaMotta...Henry Armstrong..."Bummy" Davis...Sammy Angott...Charley Burley...Lew Jenkins...Freddie Cochrane. "Thumbing" your eyes in a clinch...using his knees and elbows..."heeling" his opponents with his gloves...you name it...Zivic did it. Died in 1984 at age 71. He's been called the "dirtiest fighter" of all time.
Mysterious Billy Smith “He was always doing something mysterious. Like he would step on your foot, and when you looked down he would bite you in the ear. If I had a fighter like that nowadays, I could lick heavyweights. But we are living in a bad period all around.”
How about Two ton Galento for that title? I love to see Andy Ruíz fight, but he clearly kept hitting AJ in the back of AJ's head with the back of his hand in the first fight. Muhammad Ali kept holding without getting penalized...
I answered 'other' because in pro boxing there is no place for nice guys. You have to deliver and receive all the dirty blows/elbows etc., otherwise you don't survive. Pro boxing is a dirty game, deal with it.
Tunney " thing is with Harry anything goes, he would thumb you in the eye while stepping on your toes, also no one in the game was better at racking their gloves across your face than Greb, mind you, you could do the same back to him he never complained " nuff said. Greb " prize fighting ain't the noblest of arts, and I aint its nobleset artist " sure you have read this . Peter Wilson " of all the fighters I have seen, and I have seen thousands, the meanest, toughist, dirtiest,was a flame headed negro featherweight named Joe " sandy " Saddler "
Since we are reliving this question, Rocky Marciano as great as he was is a solid candidate for a dirty fighter with his constant head butting and low blows not to mention an occasional elbow for good measure. Muhammad Ali once mentioned Marciano as a dirty fighter after watching him fight Archie Moore on film from Sept 21 1955.
For brevity's sake: https://www.thefightcity.com/top-12...weather-bernard-hopkins-sandy-saddler-boxing/ Admittedly, I do disagree about their placement of Greb, which is explained by another of their articles on why Greb wasn't a dirty fighter: https://www.thefightcity.com/bad-rap-harry-greb-boxing/
I know there have been dirtier (Zivic, etc), but Golota deserves a special shout out for the COMBO he threw to Bowe's nuts.