Who are the 'Super 6' at 140?

No arguments with that from me. But Kotelnik needs to be more active.

 

in no particular order:

khan,bradley,matthysse,maidana,judah and kotelnik

alexander doesn't cut for me while guererro and morales needs to prove themselves more at the weight to get in

 

Amir Khan
Timothy Bradley
Marcos Maidana
Matthysse
Alexander
Judah

Alexander did beat Kotelnik

 

I agree with that but I'd switch Judah and Maidana. Also Guerrero will easily make the list if he moves up in weight well.

 

Bring Hatton back, and he'd right starch them all!

 

I would stick both Bradley and Judah above Khan though.

 

Two brutal defeats, overweight since 2009, snorting cocke and drinkin plus not much gym work... Anyone would beat him. Morales would do a number on him.

 

snorting coke and drinking plenty of alcohol doesn't make you a bad fighter, infact, from experience it makes you a better one!

 

Guerrero will be knocking on the door if he provides a good showing against Maidana.

 

Replace Judah with Holt, Morales or Garcia. Hell, anybody. :yep

 

For the record, I had Kotelnik beating both Alexander and Maidana (don't believe the hype on that one - especially since 95% of this forum probably never saw it).

He is definitely top 6, despite having the least star power on the list.

 

No he wouldn't. Bradley would give him a hell of a fight.

Let's be honest with ourselves. Hatton's invincibility at 140 was helped by the fact that the division which he ruled, was pretty weak at the time.

 

Ask this again in late August and I would be highly surprised if Ghost Guerrero isn't on this list. I think Ghost has the tools to reign supreme over all these names.

 

Hey, all the uncles are here. It's a family reunion! :happy