Tyson is only 220lbs in his prime. Toney would be around 220lbs as well. What do you mean too big? And who the hell has ever knocked out James Toney? You sound absolutely ridiculous. Tyson is more likely to break his hand on Toney's hard head than to knock Toney out. Toney has a chin that is better than Tyson's.
Tyson's inside game would destroy Toney's inside game with crippling power, delivered via uppercut to Toney's chin.
Tyson got knocked the **** out and out boxed every round by a journeyman scrub?? Remind us all when Toney has been KO'd? Tyson can't outbox or KO a focused Toney and would get lighted up like a Christmas tree..
Prime Tyson beats any version of Toney, no doubt. Prime Tyson got too much speed and great combination punching for Toney. Toney would make it a fight though. But what did y'all expect Toney to say? 'Tyson would whoop ma ass?' And one thing's for sure: Toney would not be intimidated by Tyson. Not at all.
Toney would definetly crushed Tyson when they were both fighting under Roach. Prime Tyson could have been different story.