Hey sp550i :hi: Long time no see... I always wanted to ask you; how did you score Haye vs Harrison round1?
Best 5 wins: Froch: Pascal, Dirrell, Johnson, Abraham, Taylor Calzaghe: Kessler, Hopkins, Eubank, Reid, Bika For now I have to say Calzaghe's resume is just slightly better. But Froch's will be better by the time he retires. Calzaghe has a lot of padding on his record. Froch's next-best win is over a shot Robin Reid. Calzaghe's is Jeff Lacy. There's not much after that.
Froch by far. He fought names when they mattered. Joe on the other hand was just an opportunist who had no intention of coming out of his comfort zone.
But Calzaghe's depth is greater. You can't just dismiss it. Charles Brewer Byron Mitchell Richie Woodhall Omar Sheika Mario Veit These are far better than what's left on Froch's resume. Kessler beat Froch Hopkins has beaten Pascal and Johnson. Omar Sheika beat Johnson Jeff Lacy beat a better version of Robin Reid than Froch Calzaghe is still way ahead of Froch. People are blinded by what Froch is doing now. The Super Six has created names. AA was never a top-six super-middleweight. There were far more deserving participants of the Super Six than AA, Dirrell, Green and even Johnson.
If Froch beats Ward, his resume becomes better than Calzaghe's, imo. No doubt. But even if he loses to Ward and beats Bute, his resume will be better than Calzaghe's.