the what fights did you watch today\scorecard thread.

Nice detailed summary McGrain. :good

Chagaev & Shot Holyfield both looked better against Valuev than Haye did. I agree with your point about Ruslan's fitness problems against Drummond & Skelton, hence my insistence that Wlad didn't beat a Physically Prime Chagaev.

 

Paret>>Wlad

 

I can agree with this. :good

 

Golota-Ruiz '04

Round 1: Ruiz 10-9

Round 2: Golota 10-8 (Ruiz down)

Round 3: Even 10-10 (Soley a hugging & rabbit-punching round!)

Round 4: Golota 10-9

Round 5: Golota 10-9

Round 6: Golota 10-9

Round 7: Golota 10-9

Round 8: Golota 10-9

Round 9: Ruiz 10-9

Round 10: Even 10-10 (Ruiz down a second before the bell, but performed better in the round)

Round 11: Ruiz 10-9

Round 12: Ruiz 10-9


Total: Golota 116-113

 

Lately for some reason I've made a concerted effort to watch all those tabboo fights that I never wanted to see........the ones where one fighter lost his life or nearly did. I watch them not for some sick voreuristic reason but for the historical reference, and in the possible belief that my watching the fight simply furthers the word of their effort, ultimately tragic as it my be. I will speak of it after all, and perhaps in the retelling by me and many others will their efforts have meaning for others beyond the obvious sadness.

Here is my scorecard; it was a bad hometown decision.

1: Quiroga 10-9
2: Akeem 10-9
3: Akeem 10-9
4: Akeem 10-9
5: Quiroga 10-9
6: Akeem 10-9
7: Akeem 10-9
8: Even 10-10
9: Quiroga 10-9
10: Quiroga 10-9
11: Akeem 10-9
12: Akeem 10-9

116-113 Akeem

 

Wlad-Peter I '05

Round 1: Wlad 10-9

Round 2: Wlad 10-9

Round 3: Peter 10-9

Round 4: Wlad 10-9

Round 5: Peter 10-7 (Wlad down twice)

Round 6: Wlad 10-9

Round 7: Wlad 10-9

Round 8: Wlad 10-9

Round 9: Wlad 10-9

Round 10: Even 10-10 (Wlad down, but dominated most of the round)

Round 11: Wlad 10-9

Round 12: Wlad 10-9


Total: Wlad 116-111

 

Wlad-Chagaev '09

Round 1: Wlad 10-9

Round 2: Wlad 10-8 (Chagaev down)

Round 3: Wlad 10-9

Round 4: Wlad 10-9

Round 5: Wlad 10-9

Round 6: Wlad 10-9

Round 7: Wlad 10-9

Round 8: Wlad 10-9

Round 9: Wlad 10-8 (Chagaev takes a beating)

Mentally beaten, & about to be KO'd, Chagaev quits on his stool.

Total: Wlad 90-79

A flawless & beautiful boxing masterclass by Wlad. :bbb

 

How have i not noticed this thread before!

i recently began collating all the scorecards i have that go against an official decision. here's my list

So here's my list:

De la hoya W12 Mosley 2 (115-113)
De la hoya W12 Trinidad (116-112)
De la hoya L12 Sturm (112-116)

Hopkins D4 Mitchell *based off fight reports
Hopkins W12 Taylor 1 (115-113)
Hopkins W12 Mercado (114-112)
Hopkins W12 Pascal 1 (114-112)

Wright W12 Vargas (116-112)
Wright W12 Taylor (115-113)
Wrright W12 Simon (115-113)

Martinez W12 Cintron (117-111)
Martinez W12 Williams 1 (115-114)

Lara W12 Williams (117-111)

Holyfield L12 Lewis (112-116)
Holyfield W12 Valuev (115-113)

Ruiz W12 Valuev 1 (115-113)

Malignaggi W12 Diaz (116-112)

Leonard D12 Hagler (116-116)
Leonard L12 Hearns 2 (112-114)

Froch W12 Kessler (115-113)

Alexander L12 Kotelnik (113-115)
Alexander L12 Matthyse (94-95)

Judah L12 Matthyse (113-114)

Holmes W15 Spinks 2 (144-141)
Holmes W12 McCall (115-113)
Holmes W12 Nielsen (115-113)

Rahman W12 Tua 2 (116-112)

Toney W12 Peter 1 (116-112)

Tarver W12 Johnson 1 (115-113)

Reid W12 Ottke (115-114)
Reid W12 Calzaghe (114-113)

Morales W12 D.Diaz (114-113)
Morales W12 Maidana (115-113)

Whittaker W12 Ramirez 1 (117-111)
Whittaker W12 Chavez (117-111)

Flowers W10 Walker (PTS) * based off fight reports


some of these are quite old scorecards so there could be the odd typo but i'm confident i have all the winners correct as i had them originally.

There could be a couple of fights I've not been able to track down but this is what I have so far

 

just rewatched reid vs calzaghe

R-C

1: 9-10 not much happened but joe got off a couple of clean combos and fought well behind the jab
2: 9-10 very good ring generalship by joe, slips a lot of reid's counter shots.
3: 9-10 joe dominating behind his jab, hand and head movement too quic for reid to get a foothold.
4: 9-10 joe in control here, flashy combos and some good counter jabs. reid getting flustered.
5: 10-9 reid timing joe much better in this round, slipping and landing good shots.
6: 10-9 scrappy round, reid displays better ring generalship and his punches seem more effective
7: 10-9 another scrappy round. joe held his ground better but reid still looks like the general in there and is landing the harder shots.
8: 8-10 clear joe round plus a point deduction to boot.
9: 10-9 reid looks a lot stronger than joe and is hitting him with well timed hard shots
10: 10-9 more of the same from reid with the harder cleaner punches and the superior defence.
11: 9-10 reid looked like the ring general but his defence was shockingly open to joe's right hand.
12: 9-10 good strong finish by joe, his bounce his back and he makes reid miss on the inside landind quick snappy combos.

Final score 112-115 calzaghe.

 

Wlad-Byrd II '06

Round 1: Byrd 10-9

Round 2: Wlad 10-9

Round 3: Wlad 10-9

Round 4: Wlad 10-9

Round 5: Wlad 10-8 (Can it be scored 10-7, because Byrd was dropped, then took a brutal beating?)

Round 6: Wlad 10-8 (Byrd takes a beating)

Round 7: Brutal 2nd knockdown of Byrd, followed by ref stoppage on brutal cuts.

Total: Wlad 59-53

 

Wlad-Brewster II '07

Round 1: Wlad 10-9

Round 2: Wlad 10-9

Round 3: Wlad 10-9

Round 4: Wlad 10-9

Round 5: Wlad 10-9

Round 6: Wlad 10-8 (sheer domination)

Lamon's trainer throws in the towel.

Total: Wlad 60-53

 

Do you only watch HW fights?

 

No. :nono

I've just recently started scoring fights i watch in this topic, & lately they all happen to be at Heavyweight.