Frazier: positives did it vs a younger Ali, an udefeated Ali, did it to gain respect as the true champion, and it was the fight of the century negatives Ali was off the lay off maybe still working the rust off a little incredible feat knocked Ali down Norton: positives won very clearly, beat an Ali who had been active and was hungry after Frazier, beat an Ali who was well past the lay off and was at his best since the lay off negatives didnt do it first incredible feat broke Alis jaw
agreed. and ali was clearly a bit sloppy and out of shape in that first fight. shouldn't really matter, that was his choice but to a degree it affects the win. i personally thought ali clearly took the second fight (close but clear) leading me to think, despite the stylistic challenges he presents, norton always is a step below a motivated ali. frazier took a young, fitter, closer to prime ali in a war in which both men put EVERYTHING on the line.
Norton.Beat him more convincingly and did it against a fighter that was probably on the best run of his entire life.Never beaten decisively over the course of the three fights,either.
Hmm, a clear win against a man in his prime vs. a dubious one against a past-it version. What a conundrum.
Frazier, because there was no template for how to do it. Anybody who came after him was at an advantage both tacticaly and psychologicaly.
itrymariti, why was Norton's win "dubious"? He won it clearly, and I don't buy that Ali had a broken hand at all.
For the first fight with Norton, Ali was completely disinterested. He took Norton VERY lightly. He took Frazier very seriously and was in incredible shape and fought great. The Ali who showed up for Frazier in '71 would have beaten Norton without question.
Two different types wins. Frazier beat Ali in the trenches. Norton neutralized Ali and out thought him.
With all due respect to Ken, his win over Ali isn't even on the same planet as Joe's. Hell, it's closer to the same galaxy as Larry's.
Facts He was 29 when Frazier beat him and 31 when Norton beat him He whipped Frazier twice and Knocked out Foreman AFTER he lost to Norton He never dominated Norton but he KO'ed Frazier
Both are good victories, but stylistically Norton matches up better with Ali than Frazier does. He may not be a better fighter but his results against Ali are on paper better, (They weren't better to watch mind you)